4
$\begingroup$

Assume Mars got terraformed; atmosphere, water, biosphere but didn't have its core jumpstarted somehow. How long would it take to revert back to its current state if maintainance stopped.

It has the gravity to hold O2 and N2 against thermal escape, but not water, though solar wind is a problem absent a magnetic field.

I've found a lot of material on this but there's quite a bit of inconsistency in the timeframes involved. I've seen everywhere from less than a million years to hundreds of millions of years.

I'm toying with the idea of Mars having once been terraformed, but by the modern age has reverted to what we see now.

$\endgroup$
4
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ Solar wind is a problem on a geological timescale. It will take Mars millions of years to go from a lush Earth-like to a barren dry desert. Effects will be measurable after a few hundred thousand years. For comparison, the entire history, from the dawn of civilization to our hypermodern days, is only about 5,000 years. Geological time is vastly longer than historical time, which is vastly longer than human lifetime. In other words, there is no way that a civilization will endure on anything like the timescale required for Mars to lose its water and atmosphere. $\endgroup$ – AlexP Jul 5 '20 at 17:50
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Question of whether a civilization can last so long aside, the question is how long would it take for such a terraforming to be completely undone. A few million? 50 million? 500 million? How far in the past would maintenance of the planet have needed to stop for Mars to end up looking like it does now again by this time. $\endgroup$ – Sam D. Jones Jul 5 '20 at 18:03
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ "How far in the past would maintenance of the planet have needed to stop for Mars to end up looking like it does now again by this time?" Sorry, we have no better answers than "millions of years". Maybe ten, maybe a hundred, maybe a few hundred millions of years. We will find out a better answer only when we send a team of geologists on Mars and they start dating the geological features on the planet. (continued...) $\endgroup$ – AlexP Jul 5 '20 at 18:12
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ To give you an example here on Earth. About 5 or 6 millions of years ago, the Mediterranean went through an episode of extreme dessication. It happened here on Earth, in a very well studied place. We still don't know if the dessication was (almost) complete or only partial, where it was one long episode or a series of shorter episodes, how long it took for the sea to go dry, and so on. We know it happened, we know it was severe, and that's about it. And the Mediterranean is not on another world. $\endgroup$ – AlexP Jul 5 '20 at 18:15
3
$\begingroup$

OK, we are going to Fermi Estimate this. TL;DR: about 1.5 Billion years.

Mars can never be terraformed and left alone. That is, we can never "finish" terraforming it, and will always have to replenish its atmosphere. It is simply too small and there is too much of a problem with solar wind stripping its atmosphere away. As a result, whether it can gravitationally hold on to its O2 and N2 is not important, since solar wind will always remove it.

However, that begs an important question: what level of terraforming are we talking about? There are several possibilities, of which I will study 2.

The dynamo kickstart method: Presume that you somehow did produce a large planetary magnetic field on Mars. This would be required no matter what if you want people to survive, since otherwise we'd be showered with a constant stream of high energy particles. In this method, Mars never loses most of the atmosphere you've given it, and it stays terraformed. This is boring.

The "magnetic field generators broke" method: no matter what, the terraformed Mars required a magnetic field. However, it was clearly abandoned. Why? Because its magnetic field generators broke, that's why, and they require such a tremendous amount of energy and cost to create that you just couldn't make another one. Perhaps your society collapsed and only a lucky few escaped to the primordial Earth, allowing Mars to die slowly.

So to the question: how slowly? As stated in the comments, we need to discuss the difference between "totally undone" and "measurably undone". In your question, it seems that you are asking:

Presuming that Mars was terraformed very long ago and then suddenly maintenance stopped, how long would it take for it to become indistinguishable from today's Mars, at least according to our best science?

The answer to that question is: exactly as long as Mars has existed for. So let's answer the other one: how long until Mars is uninhabitable.

It appears to be the case that the Sun, long ago, was much more active and thus stripped Mars' atmosphere away a lot faster in the past than now. That link also says something interesting: the rate of atmospheric escape on an early Mars appears to be around 6-7 times more than it is currently, which is about 1500 grams of atmosphere per second. So let's make the assumption that Mars' atmospheric escape was 7x1500 = 10500 g/s once the magnetic field generators turned off, or approximately 900,000 Kg per (modern) Earth day, and it is down to approximately 130,000 Kg per modern Earth day now.

Earth's current atmosphere weighs approximately $5\times10^{18}$ kg. Mars is about 40% the size of Earth, so let's make our lives easy and assume that its early atmosphere weighed $1\times10^{18} kg$ just before the magnetic field turned off.

Assuming that the rate of atmospheric loss reduces exponentially (which it PROBABLY does, but it also probably depends so strongly on so many other things that this is a WILD guess) the rate of loss is:

$$R_{loss} = 900000 e^{-1.3E-12 t}$$

where $t$ is in days.

We can finally solve for $t$ by making a HUGE assumption: the rate of atmospheric loss is directly proportional to the atmospheric pressure. That is:

$$P = \alpha R_{loss}$$

We don't need to know what $\alpha$ is. Watch:

Humans have survived for two years at 0.475 atmospheres of pressure, and this is the highest recorded survival, so let's assume that once the atmosphere of Mars reduces to 0.475 of its former pressure, Mars' terraforming has been "undone". Since we've assumed that $R_{loss}$ is directly proportional, this is equivalent to saying that $R_{loss}$ has decayed to 0.475x900000, or 427500 Kg per modern Earth day. The time it takes to do this is:

$$t = -\frac{\ln(\frac{427500}{900000})}{1.3E-12} = 5.5E11$$ days.

This is approximately 1.5 Billion years.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.