Skip to main content
Corrected occupation or trade
Source Link
a4android
  • 38.5k
  • 8
  • 55
  • 143

I am thinking if it's possible for craftsmen of late medieval times to achieve precision required to repeatedly make crossbows enhanced by use of cams or pulleys. As far as I know, pulleys were used in medieval societies quite often, but I don't think they were made in sizes approaching the ones required for compound crossbows.

But, assuming some medieval scientistsmilitary engineers figured out putting pulleys on ballistas or crossbows would bring some advantage and then found some skilled craftsmen to build parts and find good materials for it, would it be plausible?

Edit to address duplicate votes:
It's true that my question is really similar to this one: Rambo style compound bows, feasible with renaissance tech-level? but I believe this earlier thread was a bit more about a compound bow specifically (with features like detachable arms) and I think that answers provided under my question give some new information and thoughts on the topic.

I am thinking if it's possible for craftsmen of late medieval times to achieve precision required to repeatedly make crossbows enhanced by use of cams or pulleys. As far as I know, pulleys were used in medieval societies quite often, but I don't think they were made in sizes approaching the ones required for compound crossbows.

But, assuming some medieval scientists figured out putting pulleys on ballistas or crossbows would bring some advantage and then found some skilled craftsmen to build parts and find good materials for it, would it be plausible?

Edit to address duplicate votes:
It's true that my question is really similar to this one: Rambo style compound bows, feasible with renaissance tech-level? but I believe this earlier thread was a bit more about a compound bow specifically (with features like detachable arms) and I think that answers provided under my question give some new information and thoughts on the topic.

I am thinking if it's possible for craftsmen of late medieval times to achieve precision required to repeatedly make crossbows enhanced by use of cams or pulleys. As far as I know, pulleys were used in medieval societies quite often, but I don't think they were made in sizes approaching the ones required for compound crossbows.

But, assuming medieval military engineers figured out putting pulleys on ballistas or crossbows would bring some advantage and then found some skilled craftsmen to build parts and find good materials for it, would it be plausible?

Edit to address duplicate votes:
It's true that my question is really similar to this one: Rambo style compound bows, feasible with renaissance tech-level? but I believe this earlier thread was a bit more about a compound bow specifically (with features like detachable arms) and I think that answers provided under my question give some new information and thoughts on the topic.

Formatted a bit for readability
Source Link
Secespitus
  • 17.8k
  • 9
  • 76
  • 111

I am thinking if it's possible for craftsmen of late medieval times to achieve precision required to repeatedly make crossbows enhanced by use of cams or pulleys. As far as I know, pulleys were used in medieval societies quite often, but I don't think they were made in sizes approaching the ones required for compound crossbows. 

But, assuming some medieval scientists figured out putting pulleys on ballistas or crossbows would bring some advantage and then found some skilled craftsmen to build parts and find good materials for it, would it be plausible? Edit

Edit to address duplicate votes: 
It's true that my question is really similar to this one: Rambo style compound bows, feasible with renaissance tech-level? but I believe this earlier thread was a bit more specific onabout a compound bow specifically (with features like detachable arms) and I think that answers provided under my question give some new information and thoughts on the topic.

I am thinking if it's possible for craftsmen of late medieval times to achieve precision required to repeatedly make crossbows enhanced by use of cams or pulleys. As far as I know, pulleys were used in medieval societies quite often, but I don't think they were made in sizes approaching the ones required for compound crossbows. But, assuming some medieval scientists figured out putting pulleys on ballistas or crossbows would bring some advantage and then found some skilled craftsmen to build parts and find good materials for it, would it be plausible? Edit: It's true that my question is really similar to this one: Rambo style compound bows, feasible with renaissance tech-level? but I believe this earlier thread was a bit more specific on a compound bow specifically (with features like detachable arms) and I think that answers provided under my question give some new information and thoughts on the topic.

I am thinking if it's possible for craftsmen of late medieval times to achieve precision required to repeatedly make crossbows enhanced by use of cams or pulleys. As far as I know, pulleys were used in medieval societies quite often, but I don't think they were made in sizes approaching the ones required for compound crossbows. 

But, assuming some medieval scientists figured out putting pulleys on ballistas or crossbows would bring some advantage and then found some skilled craftsmen to build parts and find good materials for it, would it be plausible?

Edit to address duplicate votes: 
It's true that my question is really similar to this one: Rambo style compound bows, feasible with renaissance tech-level? but I believe this earlier thread was a bit more about a compound bow specifically (with features like detachable arms) and I think that answers provided under my question give some new information and thoughts on the topic.

added 420 characters in body
Source Link
Mranderson
  • 925
  • 8
  • 17

I am thinking if it's possible for craftsmen of late medieval times to achieve precision required to repeatedly make crossbows enhanced by use of cams or pulleys. As far as I know, pulleys were used in medieval societies quite often, but I don't think they were made in sizes approaching the ones required for compound crossbows. But, assuming some medieval scientists figured out putting pulleys on ballistas or crossbows would bring some advantage and then found some skilled craftsmen to build parts and find good materials for it, would it be plausible? Edit: It's true that my question is really similar to this one: Rambo style compound bows, feasible with renaissance tech-level? but I believe this earlier thread was a bit more specific on a compound bow specifically (with features like detachable arms) and I think that answers provided under my question give some new information and thoughts on the topic.

I am thinking if it's possible for craftsmen of late medieval times to achieve precision required to repeatedly make crossbows enhanced by use of cams or pulleys. As far as I know, pulleys were used in medieval societies quite often, but I don't think they were made in sizes approaching the ones required for compound crossbows. But, assuming some medieval scientists figured out putting pulleys on ballistas or crossbows would bring some advantage and then found some skilled craftsmen to build parts and find good materials for it, would it be plausible?

I am thinking if it's possible for craftsmen of late medieval times to achieve precision required to repeatedly make crossbows enhanced by use of cams or pulleys. As far as I know, pulleys were used in medieval societies quite often, but I don't think they were made in sizes approaching the ones required for compound crossbows. But, assuming some medieval scientists figured out putting pulleys on ballistas or crossbows would bring some advantage and then found some skilled craftsmen to build parts and find good materials for it, would it be plausible? Edit: It's true that my question is really similar to this one: Rambo style compound bows, feasible with renaissance tech-level? but I believe this earlier thread was a bit more specific on a compound bow specifically (with features like detachable arms) and I think that answers provided under my question give some new information and thoughts on the topic.

Post Closed as "Duplicate" by Mołot, sphennings, RonJohn, Secespitus, L.Dutch
Source Link
Mranderson
  • 925
  • 8
  • 17
Loading