New answers tagged military
8
votes
Would lightning bolts be effective against modern military vehicles?
Most of the answers above are focused on the fantasy side of things. As a former military guy I can say this is something that we do test for. When the US military issues contracts for new equipment ...
- 181
6
votes
Would lightning bolts be effective against modern military vehicles?
One point that other posters have missed is that lightning is blinding (and to a lesser degree, its thunder deafening). Military personnel and equipment will be protected against this to some degree, ...
- 5,519
4
votes
Would lightning bolts be effective against modern military vehicles?
The basic aspect of lightning is that there is an electrical potential developed between two points and that potential is suddenly shorted. Most thoughts of being able to cast lightning is using a lot ...
- 4,203
6
votes
Would lightning bolts be effective against modern military vehicles?
Depending on how much precise is the lighting bolt application, one can disable and/or destroy almost whatever of modern technology.
Natural lightnings are generally safe for modern buildings and ...
- 5,844
2
votes
Would lightning bolts be effective against modern military vehicles?
Other answers already described that Lightning Bolts are not effective along with the reasons. I also agree with all of the answers here.
However, if your magic users can conjure/control lightning ...
- 392
4
votes
Would lightning bolts be effective against modern military vehicles?
I upvoted @TheDemonLord's answer, you should too
But let's build on it. Lots of people have survived direct lightning strikes. Often with substantial long-term effects, but they survived and they didn'...
- 107k
28
votes
Would lightning bolts be effective against modern military vehicles?
Your mage is not much more dangerous than your average infantryman
Fighter jets, helicopters, warships, and submarines are all speced to take the occasional lightning strike and be fine. These are ...
- 76.1k
37
votes
Accepted
Would lightning bolts be effective against modern military vehicles?
Not effective at all.
Now - let's be charitable, some of the electronics inside modern military equipment don't like being struck by lightning and so you may get some reduced functionality if she gets ...
- 6,978
0
votes
What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant?
What is the medieval equivalent of Lego?
As many commenters above have noted, the heavier you are, the more your weight pushes down onto the ground, and this means you can be more hurt by falls. You ...
- 6,452
1
vote
What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant?
Why complicate things? Just make an extra large ballista. Shouldn't present a particularly complicated engineering task.
"Use more gun."
- 11
3
votes
What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant?
By the mid-15th century, field artillery already looked and operated like it would for the next three hundred years - just heavier for a given amount of firepower and more expensive to field. Smaller ...
- 1,290
2
votes
What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant?
The giant has to sleep sometime
Gulliver meets the Lilliputians
2
votes
What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant?
For a smaller giant, a bunch of archers is probably the easiest way. Hey, it works in Warhammer! You don't even need that many, although it might take them a while if the skin is thick. They'd have to ...
- 129
1
vote
Is this super-soldier possible in reality
Something like this could be worth doing
So there are a lot of votes for "no, this is a bad idea", but there are also some pretty good reasons to support the idea of a taller stronger super ...
- 76.1k
3
votes
What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant?
ropes on horseback. Bring her down like an ATAT
- 305
5
votes
What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant?
Initial attempts when she first appeared would probably amount to suicide missions causing only pinpricks. Once the panic settled down the citizens would have to coexist for a while. But with the ...
- 2,224
2
votes
Is this super-soldier possible in reality
Nay.
Super soldiers are a staple in many sci-fi products, but there's an inherent problem with them in a more realistic scenario: just like guns beat karate most of the time, robots beat realistic ...
- 14k
5
votes
What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant?
... not traps ...
Humans used pit traps to hunt e.g. mammoths. The animals were panicked and herded into the pit or down a cliff. But the normal humans will be unable to dig a pit 60 metres (200 feet) ...
- 106k
4
votes
Is this super-soldier possible in reality
No... just, NO!
Oh boy, where do I start with this list of abominations! At the beginning, of course.
First mistake: concentrating on improving humans, which evolution has already improved as much as ...
- 48k
2
votes
Is this super-soldier possible in reality
It's not viable.
Lesson #1 of any super-soldier or super-weapon question: The enemy gets a vote. And the enemy is not stupid.
What you have really done with all that lengthy treatment, training, and ...
- 27.9k
13
votes
What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant?
Swamps
Okay - Physics time. a 200ft Humanoid is going to weigh a lot. I haven't done the calculations, but here's another WB question: Here about this - This is for a Giant that is merely 20-30ft tall ...
- 6,978
31
votes
What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant?
Pit Trap
Mrs Giant is big and heavy. Big heavy things are more vulnerable to falls than small light things.
A three foot drop will not harm an ant. The same fall will bruise a person. They will be ...
- 60.8k
23
votes
Accepted
What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant?
Skirmishing
Attacking the giant head-on is foolish. However, warfare has known skirmishing and hit and run tactics since at least the Romans who employed velites - light infantry who would be mobile ...
- 7,824
5
votes
What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant?
Direct attacks are no realistic option. The logical choice for such a huge and moving obstacle would be to have the giant followed secretively, wait until the monster is asleep, and poison it. Arsenic,...
- 3,504
9
votes
What sort of strategies would a medieval military use against a fantasy giant?
Fire
The use of an oil accelerant coupled with an ignition source in order to light equipment and personnel on fire dates back to at least the 6th century. Lighting your giantess on fire would be a ...
- 12.9k
3
votes
Is this super-soldier possible in reality
The biology looks mostly plausible. I'm pretty sure you still have an elevated cancer risk, despite the copy number compensation, but that's only relevant if you don't get blown up within 6 months of ...
- 1,897
4
votes
Is this super-soldier possible in reality
Bigger isn't better
Firstly, it's your story so your super soldiers work because you say they work but realistically bigger soldiers are not better soldiers.
Bigger soldiers are bigger targets. If I'm ...
- 44.6k
6
votes
Is this super-soldier possible in reality
No.
First off, a disclaimer: I've probably missed a lot of what you were trying to say, and misinterpreted the rest. Your question is a big wall of text, and could use some punctuation. That said, I'...
- 9,478
Top 50 recent answers are included