2
$\begingroup$

In the dystopic/post-apocalyptic world I'm building, civilization has been split into two different societies. One is the rich who live in very large, protected cities that have giant walls surrounding them to keep out the other society, the poor.

I haven't been able to figure out a material that would be plausible in this situation, as it would have to be strong but not top heavy and light but not fragile. Cost, time, and availability doesn't matter as it is fiction, however for the plot I am looking for a material which has a major weakness. The poor society expose said weakness in later chapters and bring the walls down in one fell swoop using something such as fire. They do not have access to extremely modern weapons or anything of the sort such as nuclear weapons.

Would it be possible, under these circumstances, to have the walls be made of an already existing material? If so, what material could be used?

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ What is the level of independence for these societies? Is it like rich suburb vs ghetto in modern western city, Israel vs. Gaza strip or US vs. North Korea? If "poor society" is free to develop weapons, no wall can be of any help. $\endgroup$ – Alexander Sep 9 '17 at 0:08
  • $\begingroup$ @Alexander The poor live essentially in the wilderness with modern technology being completely absent. $\endgroup$ – Sydney Gish Sep 9 '17 at 0:17
  • $\begingroup$ Do the rich extend their government over the poor? Would they go into the wilderness to uphold laws? Or it is more like "behind the wall" lawlessness in "Game of Thrones"? $\endgroup$ – Alexander Sep 9 '17 at 0:30
  • $\begingroup$ @Alexander definitely the ladder the rich only interact with the poor when they get too close to the walls, other than that the walls are there so they can ignore them. $\endgroup$ – Sydney Gish Sep 9 '17 at 0:33
  • $\begingroup$ So, the poor would be constantly hatching plans to go over, under or through the wall. Your wall needs to be guarded, probably by some ruthless killing AI. $\endgroup$ – Alexander Sep 9 '17 at 0:37
5
$\begingroup$

Plastic bricks with an aluminum foil or tin cover, or "plastic concrete".

Plastic Bricks

enter image description here

A plastic brick building in Columbia from here.

This example is small scale, but there is no good reason that bigger blocks perhaps as big as those in the pyramids or medieval castles, but much lighter to place, couldn't be used. For example, a version of this technology developed in New Zealand can be designed to use much larger, less finely polished bricks. Imagine cubic yard sized bales of plastic turned into smooth bricks.

The world is full of plastic crap that would be readily available in a post-apocalyptic world (it could be mined from landfills or gathered from floating plastic in the sea, if necessary), can often be compressed, melted and reformed into convenient shapes. This technique is used to make plastic bricks in some developed countries. Landfills are more ubiquitous than quality quarries or old growth forests which would be good in a time period when long distance transportation of low value building materials might be a problem.

Also, once placed, the plastic bricks can be welded into a single solid surface with heat. And, plastic is forever. Most kinds don't biodegrade over time. Animals don't eat it. It isn't friendly to plants that could root in it. If it's thick enough it can handle rough weather. It isn't as brittle as glass or ceramic or brick which would be good in places with earthquakes (perhaps fracking induced as people chase scare hydrocarbon supplies) or major storms.

Also, plastic is water proof which would be attractive in coastal areas put at risk of periodic storm surges in a world where sea levels had risen due to global warming.

While the bricks in the image above are bland and gray, plastic can come in many colors and random mix of pre-apocalypse marketing driven colors could provide an ugly/beautiful aesthetic that characters could muse upon adding "local color" to the story.

The (optional) aluminum or tin cover foil would prevent it from melting in the sun or from minimal stray fire exposure, but with sufficient ignition and intentionally poked holes in the metal cover it could burn.

Plastic Concrete

A wall made of "plastic concrete":

enter image description here

Recent RPI Masters of Architecture graduate Henry Miller has devised a way to reuse waste plastic as an aggregate in cement, circumventing the energy-intensive process of plastic recycling. By grinding up landfill-bound plastic and mixing it with portland cement, Miller was able to create a material just as strong as traditional concrete made with mined aggregate.

The trouble with plastic concrete is that the temperature at which the aggregate melts is much lower than conventional aggregates used in concrete. You'd want to have your "poor" protagonists set up fires along the base like an old stone oven or fire pit and then assault the weakened material after it had baked for a few days.

$\endgroup$
6
$\begingroup$

Trinitite

trinitite

Trinitite is the glass formed by the Trinity nuclear test. The name has been applied to glass produced from any atomic event. Like all glass it is silica colored by various impurities.

At the trinity site most of the glass is bottle green in color (Fig. 1) and comprised of two glass components that differ in refractive index. The lower refractive index glass is largely silica (melted quartz) while the higher refractive index glass is a mixture of various components that can be © chemically distinguished both in conventional SEM imaging and with QEMSCAN mapping. A red glass (Fig. 1), rich in metals, is found to the north of ground zero.

The city walls could be made of this glass. For one, it would look awesome. For two, the walls could be a natural occurrence - fused crater walls from some ancient atomic event. Some structures and things from the old city might be fused into the glass.

Glass can be very strong. The walls could be smooth and impossible to climb. But glass can be shattered by sound if the resonant frequencies can be found. There is precedent for this method of bringing down city walls.

Battle of Jericho

Battle of Jericho

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I think there is a flaw in you reasoning. If the wall is made by trinitite, which is by definition an impure form of glass, it probably won't be shattered by sound alone. If it has impurities, those same impurities will probably resonate at different frequencies; so the whole wall won't react as one. Admittedly, I can't find a source for this claim, so I may well be wrong. $\endgroup$ – Liquid Sep 9 '17 at 10:12
  • $\begingroup$ @Liquid: I am sure you are right. Big crystals would be better if you needed them to shatter with sound. I am not sure where those big crystals would come from. $\endgroup$ – Willk Sep 10 '17 at 3:14
  • $\begingroup$ I read an article about Jericho several years ago. It posited that the constant tramping of the army around the city, combined with the geology of the area, very well could have combined with a sudden loud noise to cause walls to collapse. $\endgroup$ – Michael Richardson Apr 9 at 14:36
  • $\begingroup$ @MichaelRichardson - or the trumpets were to cover the noise made by the sappers. $\endgroup$ – Willk Apr 9 at 14:57
1
$\begingroup$

Basalt-Fiber Reinforced Concrete

Coming to a structure near you! I am sure people have heard of reinforced concrete with rebar, but this concrete uses basalt fibers instead. It's a bit stronger (and eco-friendlier) than rebar, and makes a stronger wall.

What is the weakness? Well, basalt fibers don't do well in cement- they usually need a coating. Destruction of this coating could lead to a section of wall suddenly crumbling.

Carbon-Fiber / Polypropelene Wall

This is the carbon fiber we currently use on car hoods / bonnets. It has a high specific strength (better than steel), so a wall of equal strength would be lighter than otherwise.

It is very bad in compression, though, and all composites have a tendency to have sudden catastrophic failure. That is, this wall would be fine one minute, and then broken the next.

Diamond-Brick Wall

Maybe someone went crazy and built a diamond wall. It need not by shiny like an engagement ring, but it certainly would resist vandalism quite well! That is, unless the vandals carried hammers.

Diamonds don't do well in fatigue, so consistent, low force loads will crack and destroy it.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.