11
$\begingroup$

As I'm sure anyone reading this knows, our body parts move via the brain signaling the appropriate muscles to contract or expand. Now, for hair to function the way it does - its texture, malleability, etc. - it doesn't seem plausible for prehensile hair to happen with a humanoid with muscles all the way up and down every strand of hair. Plus, that would probably result in a lot of blood gushing every time you got a hair cut. So how else could prehensile hair be explained while still rooted in hard science? (Or, more generally, is it possible?)

Specifically, I'm looking for a way to not only move hair, but also to do so with enough force that the user can grab onto something with it.

EDIT: There are a ton of good answers down there. I accepted the one that worked best for me, but for anyone else who wants a go at this, that's not the only one that looks like it works.

$\endgroup$
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Does it have to be hair in the technical sense, or just some sort of cranial fiber? $\endgroup$ – ApproachingDarknessFish Aug 30 '16 at 4:59
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @ApproachingDarknessFish If "some sort of cranial fiber" allows it to be possible, I might take it under consideration. $\endgroup$ – user21719 Aug 30 '16 at 5:01
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ I see that many readers already deemed it as impossible but what do they know they haven't try using superglue! erm... okay now I'm starting to regret $\endgroup$ – user6760 Aug 30 '16 at 7:04
  • $\begingroup$ Don’t be so quick to accept one of the answers! Wait at least 24 hours for more people, and thise in other timezones, to contribute creative efforts. $\endgroup$ – JDługosz Aug 30 '16 at 13:23
3
$\begingroup$

So I don't think this is really plausible using hard-science. However, you tagged this with [science-based] rather than [hard-science], and if the [science-based] tag is willing to engage in some heavy drinking and look the other way, we may be able to pull something together that looks at least somewhat science based.

I'd like to start with a prototype for the motor: Nitenol wire

Nitenol wire unwinding

Nitenol has what we call "shape memory." If high heat is applied to the wire, the phase transitions it undergoes cause it to "remember" that shape. Later, the wire can be bent into nearly any shape, and if a light heat is applied, the wire regains its shape. This has many uses in industry, particularly in the biomedical field where it lets surgeons implant something thin, and then let it acquire its shape once it is in place. If our hair had some of these shape memory properties, it could grasp things.

Of course, this is certainly far from a complete story. Nitenol's memory is a one way trip. It's actually just going from a highly energetic "stretched" form to its natural lower energy form dictated by memory of when it was last cooled from high heat. If we used nitenol for our hair, it could reach out and grab something, but it couldn't let go. If it did have a way to "let go," it would have to let go into a flaccid useless state with even less energy than its memory form. To do anything else would require the hair to be "alive" and metabolizing, and that would create a whole set of biological requirements that hair just isn't ready for (see the other answers for why).

To make this work, we're going to give [science-based] a few good shots of Absinthe, and while it's babbling on about the green fairy, we're going to make the assertion that "proteins are magical." We do some pretty spectacular things with proteins in biology, many of which are far and beyond my understanding. So let's assume we can make some pretty stellar protien structures with some remarkable properties. They can't break the laws of physics. In particular, conservation of energy is going to be a mighty challenge here, but we'll assume they're pretty darn nifty compounds.

The first challenge we'll have with prehensile hair is the need for control. If you suggest a head full of memory wire to any woman, and she'll let you know just how bad of an idea that is:

enter image description here

We're going to need to be very careful with our protien structures to make sure that we don't just create this biosphere's worst version of bed head ever. Instead, we're going to create what appears to be every woman's dream: hair that can transition from straight to curly to straight to curly. This would be very hard for a simple crystalline structure like nitenol, but isn't all that far from plausible for proteins.

To communicate with this hair, we're going to need a nervous system. However, we can't afford to have live nerves in the hair, so we're going to have to be a bit more frugal. Since [science-based] is still suffering from a pretty bad hangover at this point, let's permit the hair to be managed with an all digital signaling system. This sidesteps all sorts of complexities which arise with the real signaling systems of the human body. We can get away with this because, unlike an arm or a leg, hair is replaceable. It's constantly growing outwards, so its signaling system doesn't have to keep functioning for 70 or 80 years. Depending on how fast this hair grows, it might only have to function for 5.

We're going to want more than 2 states for each hair: curly and not. Really what we're going to want for prehensile hair is to have many addressable regions of hair, each of which can be made curly or not. Fortunately, by going digital, we can use prior art for this. There's a very well known protocol known as JTAG, which is fundamentally based on the idea of a shift register. You can connect a bunch of these devices into a line, and then begin "shifting" bits in. Every time you push a bit into the front, every device shifts one bit down the chain in order to make room for it, like a bucket brigade. We can build something like this with proteins using something like Jacob's ladder.

Jacob's Ladder

Each time you want to shift data down, you put a new protien it, and rotate the entire chain to move data along. This requires energy, but that energy can be supplied in the root, where the data originates. The root could provide all of the energy for this, because it's only signalling energy. It's not doing any real work like holding up a cup of coffee or swinging from a limb.

Perhaps each section of hair gets 8 states (3 bit shift register). They correspond to commands for what you want the hair to do. Now we can shift data to each section of hair, slowly but surely. I don't think we're going to have prehensile hair headbanging to metal with this approach, but we might be able to grab a branch like a sloth!

With JTAG, we signal that we're ready for "action" with an extra signal, TMS. This signal is sent to every part of the chain to announce to the chain "these bits are your actual command, rather than just being data to pass down the bucket brigade. Do something with it." This could be tricky and very non-organic, so I'm going to spice it up a bit. While I'm not ready to provide full-blown neurons in the hair, I do think we can do a tiny bit of processing using the energy we can transmit from the hair follicles. I'd like to give every segment of the hair a linear feedback shift register (LFSR). This is a really really simple digital device which really just mixes up the bits a bit. This doesn't really add all that much extra duty to my extravagantly overly complicated "science-based" solution, but what it does mean is that each section of hair sees a message that's slightly different than the previous section did. I'll then have the "go" message come from the tips rather than the follicle. This does a few things that are very useful:

  • It gives a signal to let the hair strand know that every single part of the strand has received the correct signal -- we've filled up all of the chain with the right bits.
  • It gives us a way to address the individual parts of the strand. Technically we could have just created a unique ID to each part, but that has a biological challenge associated with it. We have to remember that anything like hair is going to be attacked at a biological level if it has energy in it. That's why hair and nails are so resilient -- almost nothing can consume the energy in them. If I made it easy for some parasite to latch on and capture the mechanical energy from the hair, then some parasite would evolve. The randomness of using a LFSR makes it much harder for a parasite to grab any amount of energy out of the mechanical system.
  • It provides feedback, similar to the TDO line of JTAG. If the hair is not properly functioning, the creature might command part of the hair to do something, just to see where the damage is.
  • Predicting the behavior of these LFSRs is easy if you're the brain strapped to them, and have literally hundreds of opportunities to figure them out. In hair combat, it will be hard for the opponent to learn the exact structures of your LFSRs to manipulate your hair against you.

I just checked on [science-based], and it's still trying exotic solutions for the hangover I gave it, like those from this list, so I think I still have a little time left. We need to talk about energy. Nothing I've done so far has a remotely high enough power, in terms of watts, to manage prehensile hair. I've had to do this intentionally. If there's a source of power, I have to protect it biologically from parasites and such. The less universally accessible power I put in this system, the better. However, at some point, I need enough energy built up into the system to actually do something useful.

For this, I introduce "maintenance mode." One of the selectable modes for each hair segment is a low energy maintenance mode. This is most likely a very curly shape. This is the lowest energy mode which any hair segment can reach, so no matter what we do with the hair, eventually every segment reaches this curly form. The entire purpose of this form is to capture mechanical energy. The owner of the hair can manually stretch the hair, like stretching nitenol wire, adding energy into the system. If they stretch it far enough, it can eventually return to the initial high energy "straight" mode which is ready to do anything. This stores the energy in mechanical stresses rather than high energy molecules like glucose, so it should be harder for parasites to learn to take advantage of that energy source.

Also interesting would be that this charging technique could be done to individual segments. It doesn't even need to be the whole strand that is charged at once. I could see this being used two ways. One is that a person could move their prehensile hair around towards their arms, so that they can use the chemical energy in their arm muscles to store energy into their hair. This might be seen as a sort of "grooming" action, like a duck pruning their feathers.

The other interesting thing is that hair segments could "charge" each other. You could use one segment of prehensile hair to pull at another segment to recharge it. Of course this would be a lossy process. You'd expend far more energy from the donor segment than you'd gain in the recipient segment, but if it happened to be that you needed that particular section of your hair energized more, you might see it. One sign of nervousness might be the individual's hair writhing against itself trying find the best distribution of energy.

I think [science-based] may be looking my way, so it's time to make my exit. Hopefully that helped!

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ So... Did you just suggest that I make my character have wires made of protein, if I read that correctly? $\endgroup$ – user21719 Aug 30 '16 at 21:33
  • $\begingroup$ Who knows... it might taste like bacon? $\endgroup$ – nijineko Aug 30 '16 at 21:40
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @DonielF Basically, yeah. Given that hair is already protien, it isn't that big of a stretch. I think the real killer for the reasonability of this idea is the signalling. We just don't see such long digital signal chains in nature because they're notoriously fickle and nature doesn't have a reliable PCB manufacturer =) $\endgroup$ – Cort Ammon Aug 30 '16 at 21:42
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @nijineko My hope would actually be that it wouldn't taste like bacon. Much of the reason we like the taste of bacon is because the chemicals it leaves in our mouths tell us that it contains lots of nutrients and energy, in the form of meat and fat. If it tasted like bacon, that might suggest that I had failed in my goal of keeping the spare energy content of the hair down. If anything, due to the mechanical energy springing back unexpectedly, it might taste like pop rocks! $\endgroup$ – Cort Ammon Aug 30 '16 at 21:43
8
$\begingroup$

Hair that is iron-based could be manipulated with internal magnetic fields (say, just a bit of iron at the tip of each hair so it can be attracted/repelled as needed). It wouldn't have a strong grip one hair at a time, but Velcro gets lots of grip by grabbing on collectively.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ That...is absolutely genius. $\endgroup$ – user21719 Aug 30 '16 at 15:42
6
$\begingroup$

Short answer: It's not possible.

Anything that's fine enough to be hairlike won't be strong enough to grasp objects firmly. Prehensile tails require both muscles strong enough for grasping as well as the skeletal structure to support them.

Something like a cephalopod's arm wouldn't work because they're dependent on being submerged to have a full range of motion.

You could handwave the structural problems and make up some nonsense about supermaterial micro-robotic arms, but that's not really science-based.

You could rig up a system to provide hyper-precise control of 100,000 hairs in realtime. But you'd need to have many (at least 1/cm) control points for each strand of hair to be able to wrap it around something. Not to mention the computational challenges of tracking the position of every control point and the soft body inverse kinematic simulation needed to control their movement. Then you'd need an accurate map of the environment for the hair to interact with it since you'd lack any form of sensory feedback. All this for what is functionally an extra arm attached to a less structurally sound location.

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Hm. I was hoping you wouldn't say that. But that bit about a cephalopod's arm gives me an idea that I might be able to use... (Btw, welcome to Worldbuilding. Hope to see you around a bit.) $\endgroup$ – user21719 Aug 30 '16 at 5:01
  • $\begingroup$ If you're using some sort of system to send move \ don't move instructions to those numerous control points you mention, why not use the same system to retrieve sensory data from sensors on the hairs? $\endgroup$ – Sean Apr 5 '18 at 0:23
5
$\begingroup$

No, it's not possible.

Did you know that any visible hair you see is already "dead"? None of the cells in there are alive anymore.

However, if you're okay with a bunch of mini monkey tails growing out of your head you could potentially have "hair" that can grab things.

$\endgroup$
  • 4
    $\begingroup$ Gorgon gone right :P $\endgroup$ – Fayth85 Aug 30 '16 at 11:14
5
$\begingroup$

Yes, it is possible.

See cilia and flagellum.

It may not be likely on the macro scale, but it is possible. You may end up with "hair" that is the thickness of a ribbon snake, if you want any strength to it, and of course damage to the members would likely feel quite intense.

You may also not get much density to the hair per square inch of skin surface, more of a medusa effect rather than proper hair. But on the plus side it could be much more colorful than real hair, even chromomorphic!

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Cilia and flagellum. Why didn't I think of that? +1 $\endgroup$ – user21719 Aug 30 '16 at 17:42
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Scale these up on the head and in unison, they may be strong enough to do what you want. Length would be determinate so you wouldn't ever want a haircut especially since these would no doubt have a ton of nerve endings allowing the person to know how hard to grip and whether or not the surface was slippery or grippy or hot or sharp, etc. $\endgroup$ – Steve Mangiameli Aug 30 '16 at 21:21
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @Steve But the pain receptors aren't necessary. That's why in my question my concern was the blood gushing everywhere - I didn't care about how painful it would be. $\endgroup$ – user21719 Aug 30 '16 at 21:29
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ OK, so whip hair person flings their hair up to a branch where, unbeknownst to whip hair person, a 6 inch thorn is growing out of the branch. Without being able to see it, how does whip hair person know to let go without pain receptors? $\endgroup$ – Steve Mangiameli Aug 30 '16 at 21:35
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ If we were in the RPG stack exchange, I could just say "warshaper", and that would be that. ^^ Add in the Lasher prestige and the discussion would really be over. =P $\endgroup$ – nijineko Aug 30 '16 at 21:40

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy