Magic is gone from the world, with the exception of a few members of a dying civilization. Plate and chainmail armors are commonly used by the soldiers in this world (a low fantasy medieval setting). He is entrenched in a castle, with many faithful followers surrounding him. He will easily be able to cook any knights alive that manage to break through the castle's defenses. He is relatively old, but the circumstances do not allow a protracted siege. It is not feasible to send in assassins, as the garrison and the mage's followers are relatively few in number and all know each other by name (around 120 in number). A direct assault would be folly, since many of his followers are also adept in the use of fire, and could simply turn the surrounding fields to ash. The mage's main weakness is water. What would be the easiest way to defeat him?

  • 4
    $\begingroup$ The easiest way is to wait until he dies. Or did you also have a time requirement? $\endgroup$
    – Samuel
    Nov 9, 2015 at 18:08
  • 4
    $\begingroup$ I was going to try and answer, but frankly the question is far too broad. An army could overwhelm him, eventually. Can he shield himself? Can a single assassin sneak in and snipe him with a long-bow, or stab him the back? Can his food be poisoned? Why? Why not? Just how many "faithful followers" does he have? Do they posses some weaker magic as well? Could one of them be corrupted in some way? Does he ever leave the fortress, and could he be ambushed when he does? Can he teleport, or fly away? Read minds? How long is his lifespan? Can he heal himself? Etc, etc, etc $\endgroup$
    – AndreiROM
    Nov 9, 2015 at 18:11
  • $\begingroup$ RBC, AndreiROM is right. Its a potentially good question but there are far to many undefined variables, which means there are a multitude of potentially good answers. If you can define the scenario a bit more that would be helpful. $\endgroup$
    – James
    Nov 9, 2015 at 18:43
  • $\begingroup$ As a general rule of "how do I kill X," the answer always includes an understanding of the weaknesses of X. In this case, we know nothing about the mage's weaknesses. We don't even know his strengths besides the ability to "easily" cook a knight. If you don't depend on the weakness of the individual, the resulting conflict in the story will feel shallow. In addition, if you're looking for the "easiest" way, you also have to account for the strengths of X's opponents. Maybe X's opponents have ninjas that can sneak past the wizard's castle defenses! $\endgroup$
    – Cort Ammon
    Nov 9, 2015 at 19:02
  • $\begingroup$ Lure the mage to a rooftop when it's raining. Watch him melt (I assume that's what you mean by weakness) $\endgroup$ Nov 11, 2015 at 5:07

3 Answers 3

  1. Catapults.

    Nuke the sh*t out of the castle with flying rocks, you'll take care of him this way. If the mage's only power rely on fire, he won't be able to flee and wouldn't be able to melt 30-something rocks flying straight through the castle.

  2. Find a water mage

    If that's possible, find a mage that can counter his abilities.

  3. Wait for rain?

    If water is a true weakness (that negates his powers or something of this magnitude), rain would be enough to make him powerless and then you could charge the castle with everything you got.


If fire's his only power, he's as vulnerable to a siege as any other human, perhaps more so if he's the only inhabitant. So, as Samuel suggested in the comments, stay out of range, and encircle his castle in stone fortifications with round-the-clock guards, and just wait him out.

If you need him defeated more quickly than that, or he has the means (though magic or any other way) to stay self-sufficient within the walls of his keep, it gets harder. You'll need a material that is tough and fireproof but light enough to replace wood or metal shields. Dragonhide/dragonscale is a fairly common hand-wave, though typically too rare to equip more than a small band of heroes. In more real-world scenarios, tightly-woven wool stretched over wood or metal will insulate against heat and won't sustain fire, making for as good a shield as you're likely to get. Doesn't work as well for armor; a shield will more easily dissipate heat into the surrounding air instead of the wearer.

Given a sizable force of lightly-armored troops bearing these shields, you just need to get the drop on him. Some stealth may be called for; you'd need to get the soldiers into the keep fast or quietly enough that the wizard has little time to prepare. Then, simply surround him, and an attack by him in any one direction can be met with a counterattack from the flanks.

Most magicians in fantasy have more than one magical power; the magician may be able to teleport, or cast illusory images, or may control more than one element. In many fantasy worlds that aren't games, wizards have few weaknesses against ordinary humans (except a legendary hero). You'll need to invent a few limitations of the arcane craft that can be exploited.


Do the attackers have to be good guys? There are a lot of ways to beat a fire-wielding mage, but most of them are against the rules in the good guy handbook.

For example...

Get some attack dogs and train them to charge across the castle gate. Put a harness on them and attach lots of dynamite or black-powder. Let them loose. If you're lucky, the mage will hear his guards under attack and try to help by setting one of the dogs on fire. BOOM! No more front gate or front gate guards.

...and that mage will be much more hesitant to throw fireballs in the future.

Now attach bags of black dirt to your soldiers' armor, and charge the hole where the gate used to be. Proceed with standard castle storming procedures from that point on.

  • $\begingroup$ Alternative, animal-friendly version... catapult bags of black powder over the castle wall. Make the bags out of a light enough cloth that they break open on impact. Once the entire castle is coated in black powder, the mage would have to be a fool to use his power. $\endgroup$ Nov 9, 2015 at 18:43
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ The protagonist in Wanted is ostensibly a good guy, but he singlehandedly decimates the outer defenses of the Fraternity's stronghold and solves New York's rat problem in one fell swoop. At what point does turning a living thing into a bomb cross the line and become counter to the good guy's M.O.? $\endgroup$
    – KeithS
    Nov 9, 2015 at 18:46

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .