-2
$\begingroup$

I'm trying to create a character with complete mastery in the skill of reading and manipulation. However, how far could one with pinnacle skill in manipulation go in terms of what they're able to influence and manipulate without the skill being a superpower or supernatural in nature?

Taking reference from other characters like Johan Liebert from Monster where he was able to manipulate people into committing suicide with just a conversation or plunging a town into chaos by driving the townspeople into killing one another through paranoia. Would such feats be in the capacity of a peak social manipulator?

How far could my social manipulator go and what would be his limitations?

$\endgroup$
3
  • $\begingroup$ Comments are not for extended discussion; this conversation has been moved to chat. $\endgroup$
    – L.Dutch
    May 23 at 19:15
  • $\begingroup$ Let us continue this discussion in chat. $\endgroup$ May 27 at 19:18
  • $\begingroup$ This question trivialized history: A failed austrian Painter that was unfit to lead military managed to make larger countries bend to his will and plummet the world into a world war! $\endgroup$
    – Trish
    Jun 15 at 18:53
2
$\begingroup$

It seems that you are asking about psychological manipulation. It is, indeed, a powerful tool but feats like you are describing are close to impossible:

able to manipulate people into committing suicide with just a conversation

This is only possible if the manipulator deals with an already suicidal person who just needs one final push. A mentally healthy person is very unlikely to commit suicide since survival is a very strong biological imperative.

or plunging a town into chaos by driving the townspeople into killing one another through paranoia

This is not entirely impossible, but it would require a town with at least two distinct cultural groups with a long history of mutual hatred and prolonged efforts to sabotage the existing 'peaceful' status quo and plant paranoid ideas into the heads of town inhabitants. It may take years to turn occasional brawls into full-scale warfare.

Psychological manipulation requires a very good understanding of other people, their emotions, their value systems, and their vulnerabilities. In addition, a person being manipulated should be somewhat lacking self-awareness and be in a vulnerable state. It is extremely hard to manipulate psychologically mature people who live fulfilling and stable lives.

The main limitations for psychological manipulation are:

  • cultural and linguistic barriers

Culture and language influence our thinking, perception, emotions, and decision-making. It is harder to manipulate people who belong to a different culture and receive manipulative messages in a non-native language. Bilinguals also have higher resistance to external influences as opposed to monolinguals.

  • personalities of people being manipulated

As mentioned before, psychologically mature people are hard to manipulate. Other factors that can increase resistance to manipulation are high emotional intelligence, satisfaction with one's life and personality, cold and/or detached attitudes, hard personalities, no previous psychological trauma, effective coping mechanisms.

  • time

A short conversation may be enough to goad someone into buying thing they do not need. However, even the most skilled manipulators will struggle to achieve something bigger in such a limited time. The bigger goals of the manipulation the more time is required. It will take months or even years of sustained effort to convince an entire town to do something they haven't planned already.

  • resources that a manipulator has access to

It is impossible to manipulate big groups of people without access to significant resources. These resources may be human, financial, or social. You have to have a well-oiled propaganda machine to convince the entire nation to commit atrocities.

  • social norms and institutions that resist manipulation

Manipulation on a grand scale is only possible when society fails to protect its members. Different societies implement different protective measures. Some examples of these measures include term limits for politicians, recommendations to seek multiple opinions, mandatory cooldown periods, limits on deposits, various protection and investigation agencies that deal with cults, abuse, etc., laws against hate speech, self-censorship by media, and alike.


Theoretically, an extremely skilled manipulator can manipulate the entire global population. It does not mean that every single person will be manipulated, some people may keep clear heads and see through the manipulation. However, the situation will be outside their control. Additionally, manipulation on this scale will require years of preparation, this cannot be done in a day or two. Also, there is no guarantee that it will be sustainable in the long run.

$\endgroup$

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.