This is the sequel to Figuring Out Giganto and covers the potential adverse effects of Gigantis, namely excessive size.

You see, Gigantis defies the square-cube law, allowing for the strength of a Giganto's body's support systems (muscle, bone, thermoregulatory and circulatory/respiratory systems) to increase proportionately with size. It also keeps speed and metabolism the same as size increases. (Look at the question for greater detail.)

However, this allows it to grow to ridiculous sizes, becoming stronger and tougher as it grows, until it's about the size of a mountain. I don't want that. Contrary to appearances, I want the humans in my setting to live, which is why I made Enchantments a thing. Thus, something has to keep Gigantos in a reasonable size range.

My current ideas are:

1. Parasitism: Eating a creature gives you its Enchantment, so logic follows that if you eat part of a creature, you gain part of its Enchantment. This means otherwise innocuous parasites, leeching off a Giganto's body, will also be leeching off its magic and therefore inhibiting its size.

If what I've heard about smaller theropods eating off sauropods, essentially acting as large parasites, is true then Chompers and Plop could fulfill this function, gaining their growth abilities from Gigantos.

2. Predation: The larger a Giganto, the more Chaos Energy it has. Chaos Energy is the force behind leveling, the stuff that fuels Enchantments, so magical creatures (AKA monsters and adventurers) will be drawn to Gigantos, especially powerful monsters that take more CE to level up. Thus, it's not that they can't become bigger, it's that they don't because the big guys always get killed and/or eaten before too long.

However, this could easily backfire; Gigantos are conscious of their own Enchantment, they know what it does, so it makes sense that young Gigantos will try to hunt down and eat older, bigger Gigantos so they can get just as big and strong, and vice versa. This predation would thus be counterproductive, as it would allow Gigantos to become even bigger than a mountain.

3. Parenting: Hatchlings and young Gigantis are relatively small and weak compared to their adult selves, so it seems that predators would target them. Thus, Gigantos need to reach a large size, namely 5x larger than a meter long hatchling minimum ASAP before they can be realistically safe.

There are only two solutions for this: one, the Gigantos vigilantly defend their offspring, even with their very lives, or two, one or both of the parents gets eaten by said offspring. One comes with the issue of granting Gigantis to whatever killed the parents, making parental defense effectively useless for my purposes, and the second seems counter to natural selection. I know some insects pursue similar strategies (one word: matriphagy), but why would mutant theropods do the same?

Thus, because I am at my wit's end here, I am asking: What Strategy Would Best Keep Giganto Size In Check?

Specifically, which strategy would be most efficient and create the least amount of dangerous (as in dangerous to medieval Europeans) monstrosities?

  • 5
    $\begingroup$ This isn't an answer since it violates your precondition, but why not tweak your metabolism slightly? Rather than being constant, it goes up slightly with size, just enough so that a maximum size is imposed simply by the rate it can eat. $\endgroup$
    – Gene
    May 17, 2021 at 18:51
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Great idea Gene, that would make sense.... $\endgroup$
    – Alendyias
    May 17, 2021 at 19:31

1 Answer 1


Their muscles and bones keep getting stronger to support their cubically-increasing weight, but the Earth sure doesn't.

Take a page from buildings. Extremely large and heavy objects without robust foundations or large surface areas making contact with the ground will eventually sink, particularly if the ground is very soft. (If their proportions remain the same, then doubling the size and octupling the weight of a Giganto doubles the pressure its feet exert on the ground.) Thus, the only Gigantos that are seen running around are those that are still small enough to go out and hunt their food; once they get too large, they inevitably get trapped in bogs or other wet ground at some point in their life, and die of suffocation or starvation.

  • $\begingroup$ Great answer! Hilarious start, simple and effective overall. $\endgroup$
    – Alendyias
    May 17, 2021 at 19:31

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .