I am working on a speculative evolution project, which takes place in a reducing atmosphere consisting mainly of methane, nitrogen gas, hydrogen gas and carbon dioxide, along with liquid ammonia as the solvent. This is a pretty reducing atmosphere, thus i dont know what will organisms consume and create energy from. I have recieved couple suggestions like:

  • Using acetylene as fuel and hydrogenate it.
  • Methanogenesis
  • Hydrazine (as fuel) from ammonia and hydrogen gas
  • Diborane and Ammonia to create borazine
  • People on reddit also suggested reacting hydrides and water (and also reduction to silanes) etc

I have not rejected all of them, but i would like to receive some more ideas (and speculate upon them)!

What i am looking for is a fairly rough picture of how these creatures consume and get energy to run their bodies. Photosynthetic and heterotrophic suggestions are both fine. My requirements are as follows:

Follows something like (for photosynthesis as heterotrophy would just run the reverse, with different intermediaries)

$CH4 + (NH3) + x --> y + jH2$ where () denotes optional

i.e: uses methane (and optionally, ammonia) and other stuff to create j number of Hydrogen molecules and a sugar analogue that could power the body by hydrogenating it (and release methane along with other compounds used). This sugar analogue would be needed to release fairly enough (at least 1/6th of energy released by earthlings) energy to power organisms. This sugar analogue should be able to be utilised as a solid

Thanks for reading!

  • $\begingroup$ I don't think CO2 and NH4 work together especially if any water is present as they will react to form ammonium carbamate and carbonates. Carbon dioxide is slightly acidic and ammonia is strongly alkaline. $\endgroup$
    – Slarty
    May 6 at 7:24
  • $\begingroup$ so almost no co2 in the atmosphere? That'd be fine $\endgroup$ May 6 at 8:13

You propose acetylene as a glucose substitute. That has been mooted elsewhere on this stack. Yes yes, well and good.

But what about cyanide?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_cyanide CH4 + NH3 → HCN + 3H2

Cyanides exist on Titan and presumably other planets with reducing atmospheres like yours, and like the early Earth. The formation of CN is endothermic.

The standard enthalpies of formation of HCN(g) and P(CN)3(g) at 298.15 K were determined by ab initio molecular orbital calculation as 137 ± 10 and 493 ± 15 kJ mol−1

and abiogenic cyanide is formed via sparks (lightning), ultraviolet radiation and the like.

On your world, biology harnesses energy sources and captures the energy as cyanide. Energy can then be released by hydrogenation of cyanide back to methane and ammonia.

Cyanide is not an intrinsically better energy storage molecule than acetylene. But cyanide is cooler, because nitrogen chemistry is the stuff of life. Vinyl cyanide can do some of the things phospholipids do for us.
And from another idea on this stack that captured my imagination - Augmenting melanins with Prussian blue?

prussian blue

Thats, right. The sweet blue symmetry that is Prussian Blue. A cyanide based lifeform could store its cyanides as Prussian blue. But more than that - prussian blue composites with subsituted metals (nickel, cobalt) is electrochemically active. The chloroplast equivalent of your creatures is a blue organelle based on metal nucleated cyanide which transfers environmental electrochemical energy into chemical reactions.


Prussian blue, its analogues and their derived materials for electrochemical energy storage and conversion

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks for the answer! Also can life reduce highly oxidised compounds like peroxide/nitrate/sulfate as fats and carbs as we oxidise heavily reduced fats and carbohydrates? $\endgroup$ May 9 at 4:46
  • $\begingroup$ @TheMushroom: I think peroxides are unstable and take care of themselves but sulfates and nitrates are definitely reduced by life. My understanding is that in our world these oxidized substances are used as the oxidants instead of using oxygen gas - read up on nitrate reducing bacteria. $\endgroup$
    – Willk
    May 9 at 17:00
  • $\begingroup$ I am thinking about ammonia worlds. I am thinking about things that use energy to strip hydrogens from ammonia, leaving them with hydrogen to reduce other molecules and N2 gas to do nothing forever. Over time they would change the environment of their world. $\endgroup$
    – Willk
    May 9 at 18:44

You can use $H_2S$, as it is used by anaerobic bacteria on Earth

Hydrogen sulfide is a central participant in the sulfur cycle, the biogeochemical cycle of sulfur on Earth.

In the absence of oxygen, sulfur-reducing and sulfate-reducing bacteria derive energy from oxidizing hydrogen or organic molecules by reducing elemental sulfur or sulfate to hydrogen sulfide. Other bacteria liberate hydrogen sulfide from sulfur-containing amino acids; this gives rise to the odor of rotten eggs and contributes to the odor of flatulence.

As organic matter decays under low-oxygen (or hypoxic) conditions (such as in swamps, eutrophic lakes or dead zones of oceans), sulfate-reducing bacteria will use the sulfates present in the water to oxidize the organic matter, producing hydrogen sulfide as waste. Some of the hydrogen sulfide will react with metal ions in the water to produce metal sulfides, which are not water-soluble. These metal sulfides, such as ferrous sulfide FeS, are often black or brown, leading to the dark color of sludge.

Several groups of bacteria can use hydrogen sulfide as fuel, oxidizing it to elemental sulfur or to sulfate by using dissolved oxygen, metal oxides (e.g., Fe oxyhydroxides and Mn oxides), or nitrate as electron acceptors.

The purple sulfur bacteria and the green sulfur bacteria use hydrogen sulfide as an electron donor in photosynthesis, thereby producing elemental sulfur. This mode of photosynthesis is older than the mode of cyanobacteria, algae, and plants, which uses water as electron donor and liberates oxygen.

The biochemistry of hydrogen sulfide is a key part of the chemistry of the iron-sulfur world. In this model of the origin of life on Earth, geologically produced hydrogen sulfide is postulated as an electron donor driving the reduction of carbon dioxide.

  • $\begingroup$ Can you use h2s in a reaction like this: H2S + 6CH4 --> C6H6 + 10H2 + S $\endgroup$ May 6 at 7:13

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.