8
$\begingroup$

I want to create a glutton creature that can open its mouth wider than the prey item like snakes do, but also can bite through that big hard object and even chew it; this creature doesn't swallow prey whole but instead bites or chews the major part of it in a single bite.

I want to know if this is possible and, if so, what the musculature/anatomy/biomechanism looks like.

I feel this is a contradiction, but correct me if I am wrong and this is actually achievable or exists in real life.

  • It just has one mouth/jaw, so no double mouth like xenomorph in Alien movie or moray eel.

  • I am not asking about other methods to shred or chop off the big part (for example: crocodiles spin to bite off the meat chunk)

  • Its bite is large enough to encompass something like half of the prey's body, so no small bite to eat its prey.

$\endgroup$
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ The sole reason snakes can open their mouth that wide is because they swallow their prey whole. On the flip side, creatures with a powerful bite strength don't need to open their mouth that large. $\endgroup$ – Halfthawed Mar 25 at 6:02
11
$\begingroup$

Combination sudden gape and blades for jaws? Dunkleosteus!

https://ucmp.berkeley.edu/vertebrates/basalfish/placodermi.html

Placoderms bore heavy bony armor on the head and neck, often with an unusual joint in the dorsal armor between the head and neck regions; this joint apparently allowed the head to move upwards as the jaw dropped downwards, creating a larger gape.


Feeding mechanics and bite force modelling of the skull of Dunkleosteus terrelli, an ancient apex predator

dunkleosteus skull joints

The central result of this study is that D. terrelli used this unique four-bar linkage in the skull to achieve high speeds during jaw opening and transmit extremely high bite forces to its prey during jaw closing. Dunkleosteus appears to have had a rapid gape expansion, going from closed jaws to peak gape in as little as 20 ms and completing the feeding cycle in 50–60 ms...

Dunkleosteus also had one of the most powerful bites in vertebrate history... These bite forces greatly exceed the bite forces collected for all other fish species that have been reported and those for most modern mammalian predators, including the spotted hyaena... The only reports of higher bite forces are those found in some extremely large alligators and dinosaurs.

Dunks here could gape wide because not only could it swing its jaw down, it could swing its head and upper "teeth" up. It apparently fed like a largemouth bass, creating suction and pulling things in. But the bass stops with that and eats things whole. Dunks pulled things in and then bit them in half with all time historical superbite. Those blade jaws are scary sweet. In a story I wrote the dragon had a head like Dunks.

$\endgroup$
5
$\begingroup$

@Ryan_L makes a very good objection: there's little chance of this "double purpose jaw" evolving.

You can start with a human-type jaw. Then, we introduce an environmental change - something happens so that there's a big advantage in being able to swallow something whole. It can be anything, say a fruit. Somehow this fruit pops out for very little time and there's a race to who eats it first.

Being able to snatch it in a single mouthful becomes a marked advantage, but now the jaw gets stressed. Subluxation of the temporomandibular joint becomes frequent, and therefore, having an easily-fixed mandible is now advantageous.

Very soon in evolutionary terms, the mandible becomes only weakly attached to the cranium, but the masseter muscles develop into a sort of double trapeze: when you bite, first the jaw gets locked securely into place by the longer muscle, then leverage is applied by the shorter, more powerful transversal muscle.

Now you can take large bites, and still chew.

And it turns out that the fruit you eat doesn't get properly digested from the fruit's point of view (the "fruit" is a bribe the plant "pays" to animals so that they will defecate the seeds far and wide. It's fine tuned to attract, or be more visible to, the most useful animals). Seeds swallowed by our guys are less likely to sprout. Fruits partially eaten by other animals get a better chance. Which means that larger fruits have a selective advantage going for them: they don't get eaten whole, and/or get splattered every which way, seeds included.

There's now a selective advantage in having a wider mouth, or a more elastic mandibular joint: you can eat more fruit, of a kind your competitors aren't equipped to snatch away.

An "arms race" starts between the plants that grow larger fruit, and our guys who develop larger mouths.

After some time (waves hands quickly) the upper jaw also gets modified and can be partially extroflected, but now the oesophagus is stressed and the neck must start enlarging and becoming more flexible.

In the end, if everything goes exactly right, you might get something midway between a Great Shark mandible, a snake's jaw and a Xenomorph telescopic dentures. A second set of mobile jaws inside the first, like a snail's radula, can be used to "chew" the captured food so that it can be swallowed more easily.

The "eating" would then consist in our guy fully extending its jaws, until they are wider than its now toad-like head, and engulfing the food, remaining in a quite embarrassing and ridiculous position until the inner jaw "walks" the outer jaw to fully enclose the mouthful and start closing on the other side. Meanwhile, the inner jaw is also worrying at the food, scraping away matter that gets ingested. Finally, the mouthful is completely in, the underjaw fully distended, and our guy sports a large bulge under its chin and neck.

(This is the point where the jaw can become separated into two horizontal halves).

The inner jaw can maybe "rotate" slowly the mouthful to scrape all sides, so that it gets progressively smaller until it can fit in the distended oesophagus and finish its journey in the stomach.

$\endgroup$
4
$\begingroup$

Sharks

The jaws of sharks are not firmly affixed to the rest of their skulls, allowing them to come down and forward when striking, opening much wider than you'd expect given the position of the mouth on the sharks' head. To help this, their snouts will also hinge upwards to help get it out of the way.

As examples, some comparison photos:

Mako, mouth closed:

Mako, mouth closed

Mako, mouth open:

Mako, mouth open

Great White, mouth closed:

Great White, mouth closed

Great White, mouth open:

Great White, mouth open

And just to show that the filter-feeders get in on the action, too, Whale shark, mouth closed:

Whale shark, mouth closed

Whale shark, mouth open: Whale shark, mouth open

You wouldn't quite reach snake-like levels of "eating things larger than their head", but 70-80% of it should be doable.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ i want it to eat or bite things larger than their head though. $\endgroup$ – Li Jun Mar 25 at 6:43
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Don’t forget the goblin shark! With a slightly different skull structure, I don’t see why the same jaw mechanism couldn’t allow eating things larger than its head. $\endgroup$ – Peter LeFanu Lumsdaine Mar 25 at 23:36
2
$\begingroup$

The jaw could have two configurations. One, in which it's only loosely attached like a snake's, and another where it is firmly fixed like most other animals. Imagine if the joint worked like a with a lock and key. In the loose state, it's like the door is unlocked, you can move it easily. Put the key in and turn it, and the door won't move because the bolt of the lock is in the way. Maybe your animal's jaw is like that; it has an extra joint that it can "lock" to increase how much force it can handle at the cost of range of motion.

I think this should be possible, but it comes with some problems. First, the jaw muscles have to be strong enough to "bite off big chunks" like you said. This means they might also be strong enough to break the jaw if something goes wrong with the locking mechanism.

Second, there could be a problem with the lock that won't let it open. Many diseases and injuries change the shape of bones. If one happens in the lock, it will seize up.

Third, I'm not sure this could evolve naturally. Evolution works in baby steps, but this feature only works when it's complete. What series of minor improvements could turn a normal mouth into this new kind of mouth? Compare it with how eyes evolved to see what I mean. Eyes started as just a patch of cells that could detect light and shadow. Then as this got more precise, they slowly evolved transparent protective coverings. These slowly changed shape to be lenses so the photosensitive cells could now discern images, not just light and dark. While this was happening, creatures also evolved to have more than one, so they could watch a wider field of view, and in the case of predators, they could have depth perception thanks to triangulation. You can see how this is lots of tiny changes, not one big leap. How do you get this new mouth in tiny changes?`

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I'm not sure that this feature would only work when complete. The baby steps could be rather simple. Imagine an omnivore snake-like creature that eats typical snake prey and nuts and seeds. Then, some change in environment causes the prey to become scarce, so the creature must depend more on nuts and seeds than on its normal. Those creatures with a stronger bite-force would be better able to compete for the seeds. But creatures with smaller mouths would be unable to eat their normal prey. So that scarcity leads to creatures with strong, wide mouths. $\endgroup$ – Nick2253 Mar 25 at 22:36

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.