The technical challenges for Breakthrough Starshot list the huge amount of power required for accelerating a solar sail to interstellar travel speeds and the precise targeting of laser beams of that energy as difficulies.

On the other side, laser emission from deep space are not unheard of

astronomer Donald Menzel who first observed and classified this particular planetary nebula in the 1920s (it is officially known as Menzel 3 after him) was also one of the first to suggest that in certain conditions natural ‘light amplification by stimulated emission of radiation’ – from which the acronym ‘laser’ derives – could occur in nebulae in space. This was well before the discovery of lasers in laboratories.

Being able to detect the laser emissions as such great distances (8000 ly) will require immense level of power at source (immense by the measure of what humans can control today), so lasing will happen accross large optical paths in an actually very rarefied nebula gas (roughly one light year across with particle densities of 100 to 10,000 particles per cm3)

Closer to home, however, we have - kinda readily available - higher gas densities in higher percentage of excitation/ionization.

  1. Can one use the Earth's aurorae as a lasing medium? (IR and VIS)
    How about Jupiter's? (UV)

  2. could Sun's corona act as an acceptable lasing medium? If positive, in what wavelengths?

  3. is there any other medium inside the Solar system that may exist in "pumped enough state" to support lasing?

  4. if one can use any of the above as lasing media, what are the challenges of approaching the things from this angle for a solar sail propulsion of the Breakthrough Starshot kind? Examples (but please feel free to list any other challenges one may plausibly think):

    • precise focusing may be a problem, but only if one cannot generate enough power for the focusing to not be an issue, at least on the acceleration leg inside the Solar system
    • radiation wavelength may impose some special approaches be taken in the construction of the solar sail.
    • if a non-Earth setup is necessary, one will likely need to place the starting point of the solar sail closer to the body used for lasing. What challenges would this create?

Note: this is "science-based" - speculations are encouraged as long as they are plausibly based on scientifically known facts (of course, the answers are not required to pass the review process for publication in a science journal).

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ I remember reading years ago some talk about using the outer layers of a star as a lasing medium, but I haven't been able to find anything on the same subject from a reputable source since then. The subject was touched upon in another question but no really useful answers were forthcoming. $\endgroup$ Commented Feb 25, 2020 at 9:57
  • $\begingroup$ @starfishprime 'The 3 body problem' uses as a major plot element a handwaved solar amplification of an EM signal as a way for sending a SETI-like broadcast (4 those who may not know what's about: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Three-Body_Problem_(novel) ). Not as a lasing medium, tho' $\endgroup$ Commented Feb 25, 2020 at 10:06
  • $\begingroup$ Look on YouTube for TEA (Transverse Excited Atmospheric pressure) air lasers. A UV laser you can build at home with almost no tools, runs on any high voltage source (even a Wimshurst or Van de Graf static generator). Lasing medium is (the nitrogen in) atmospheric pressure air. $\endgroup$
    – Zeiss Ikon
    Commented Mar 24, 2020 at 18:35

1 Answer 1


could Sun's corona act as an acceptable lasing medium? If positive, in what wavelengths?

Possibly (see paper).

You need:

  • a very hot star (20000 to 50000 K)
  • with significant He content
  • also, a star with important stellar wind to create a medium density gradient.

So, basically, a Population I Wolf-Rayet star. When those conditions are met, then the star's plasma sheets, or for relatively colder starts its coronal mass ejections, can establish a lasing regime.

Expected wavelengths are in the blue-green parts of the spectrum, but ultraviolet (320.3 nm) is also cited in the paper.

The problem I see is that to use a WR star as a propulsion source, you must be located on a planet orbiting that same WR star, which would be not at all healthy.

  • $\begingroup$ This is incorrect. A red dwarf stars solar wind in a close orbit can be used as a gain medium as can our own sun. The mirrors would just have to be really big. $\endgroup$ Commented Nov 12, 2023 at 8:39

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .