Elves are an innately magical species that produce Mana from their souls to power their magi-technology. Due to this,their entire society revolves around magitech that make them far superior to all others. However, there are a sub-species of elves called the drow that are twisted reflections of their cousins. Ancient shenanigans have left this sub-species stripped of their magic. Instead, an anti-magic field constantly emanates from their souls, producing an anti-magicl aura around them. This aura disrupts magical items in their close proximity, and makes them resistant to magical attacks. Due to their lack of magic, they are also able to use iron and steel, materials that is kryptonite to normal elves. These make up the bulk of dark elf weaponry as they are the weakness of their enemies.

Iron is traditionally super effective against elves. Therefore, the natural inclination is to use ranged weaponry against the drow in order to avoid closing the distance between them. However, there is a problem. Warfare among elves is similar to medieval style warfare. Technology is powered by the Mana in elves souls, which means that it needs to be held by them to work correctly. Weapons like arrows, bullets, etc, would become weaker the farther away they are from the source.

How would I fight a drow army when ranged weapons are useless?

  • 3
    $\begingroup$ Uh, arrows work even in the absense of magic, y'know. $\endgroup$ Commented Dec 13, 2019 at 19:47
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Arrows and bullets already become weaker the further they travel. What's causing magically fired arrows/bullets to become even weaker beyond that? $\endgroup$ Commented Dec 13, 2019 at 19:47
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ You don't need magic to empower a bow. Pulling it back works normally works pretty well. And the solution to these things is always 'use magic indirectly', i.e. re-channel a river at them or something. Magic is awesome, it's a waste to use it for pulling back bows. $\endgroup$
    – Halfthawed
    Commented Dec 13, 2019 at 19:54
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Punji sticks. All of the punji sticks. $\endgroup$
    – Marbrand
    Commented Dec 13, 2019 at 20:50
  • $\begingroup$ TOW magictech missiles $\endgroup$
    – DKNguyen
    Commented Dec 13, 2019 at 22:05

3 Answers 3


There are a few general tactics that apply to your Magitech soldiers

  • Capitalize on the Drow's anti-magic ability
  • Use magic and magitech indirectly
  • Train soldeirs to fight like a Drow

For the first point, MongoTheGeek has brought that up -- magic up something that is safe to be around that becomes dangerous when the magic is removed abruptly. A pit trap with a magical safety to allow people to walk on will basically trigger when an anti-magic drow walks on it. Pick your style of trap for this one.

The concept holds that in the absence of detecting magic, that you create a battlefield that is safe for the magical and a death trap for the anti-magic drow. Pit traps, land mines, falling anvils, snares ... pick your trap and magical safety and you have ideas.

If your magic has safety valves so this doesn't happen, then you either can't do it or you need spells/magitech that bypass these safety checks. Elfie wants big boom.

Since the elves have to be close to the magic so that it does not collapse on its own, they are the scouts and snipers. It will be all about finding the sweet spot of distance that lets the spell hold for them but fail once the drow disrupts it.

The second point works on the idea that so long you aren't trying to directly magic a drow, their inherent anti-magic cannot negate it. It tends to be the common loophole when dealing with kind of power. In this case, since the drow have an anti-magic aura of a non-specific size, the idea of blowing them up to destroy their stuff might not be a vaild one so a bit more creativity might be needed.

As an example, you use a spell to switch the places of a boulder-sized hunk of dirt and the air above the drow. The spell is over, but gravity is a harsh mistress and pulls the dirt down to the ground -- ideally directly on top of the hapless drow. And if you took the dirt from just below the ground, the drow could fall into the new hole, then get buried.

Magically cut down a tree and let it fall on people is another example. Lifting the ground out from under the drow might be an interesting idea if their aura is small enough to reach enough dirt.

The third point is to basically train a select group to fight in melee against a drow unaugmented by magitech or even just magic as a whole. Since the drow's weapons are going to be really good against the other elves, their combat style will reflect the idea that the first hit might be the only one needed to kill them or otherwise remove them from the fight.

Ranged weapons here won't be totally useless, but they will need to rely on being purely non-magical both in weapon and ammunition. This might be anathema to the elves' usual line of thiniking so it might not even be considered. Likewise their normal magitech is not useless in preparation, but they are required to be able to fight without it.


It's not the fall that kills you, it's the sudden stop at the end

I'm magic. I'm good at magicking things. I magic together a bunch of really hard sharp rocks in a paper bag that I tie off with a magic string.

When I say a bunch of really hard sharp rocks, I'm talking a good quarry's worth. But it all fits neatly into a tiny little package that can be carried and hidden under a thin layer of dirt, the magic will keep it all nice and safe and secure for a good decade or more.

If that magic suddenly goes away something 1L in volume expands a million times and rather rapidly.

  • $\begingroup$ Combine that with a magitech tow missile and you have a magical version of an anti-tank missile with a shaped charge $\endgroup$
    – DKNguyen
    Commented Dec 13, 2019 at 22:07

Giant Magnets

As you have said, the Drow primarily use iron and steel as their weapons. Assuming that they become no different from magicless elves without them, depriving them of their weapons seems to be a good way to fight their army.

Although the Drow have anti-magic fields, you have mentioned that this is only for things in close proximity. Making use of their Magitech, the Elves can create supermassive magnets to place around their buildings and warzones, forcing the Drow to put down their metal weapons, and lose their only superiority to Elves.

Pre-cast Magic

At this point, with no metal armor or highly effective weapons, the Drow would be sitting ducks for the Elves. To effectively use their magic, the Elves can make use of the magic before the anti-magic aura comes into effect. Instead of hurling magic fireballs, the Elves could light their arrowheads with it. Instead of using magic bullets, the elves can use magic to accelerate bullets or arrows to the speed of sound. By pre-casting the magic, there is nothing the Drow can do to impact their superior use of Magitech. The weaponless and armorless Drow would be quickly mowed down by Magitech, once they are deprived by the Magnets.


Of course, with the introduction of these warfare tactics, the Drow and Elves would have to find some sort of balance. The Drow would probably turn to catapults and other artillery to try to destroy the Magnets before any sort of melee warfare, and excel at short-range skirmishes due to their melee combat experience and anti-magic fields. Conversely, the Elves would have to try to protect the Magnets and make use of their augmented weaponry to shoot down the Drow from long range.


You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .