1
$\begingroup$

Quite literally.

I have an idea for a world I want to make in which the ability to use magic is about as easy as something like learning how to code. It would be taught in schools, professions would be built around it, and it would become a part of our everyday lives, whether we're aware of it or not. Kind of like electricity.

How does my society not destroy itself instantly? Whether it be a single big bad evil guy who wants to explode half a continent or a nation of people seeking to mindcontrol the population of the Earth, how do I make society run about as smoothly as it does in a non-magical society?

(I'm aware that the a magical and non-magical society would probably be very different, but I'm currently more concerned about how to control a magical society before thinking about how a magical society would be different).

$\endgroup$

closed as too broad by Renan, Morris The Cat, Frostfyre, John, Cyn says make Monica whole Aug 19 at 19:50

Please edit the question to limit it to a specific problem with enough detail to identify an adequate answer. Avoid asking multiple distinct questions at once. See the How to Ask page for help clarifying this question. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 3
    $\begingroup$ In our society we teach elementary chemistry in schools, and the use of advanced chemistry is part of everyday life; sophisticated chemical formulations are availble to buy in supermarkets, and all sorts of people know how to use them to remove stains, or to unclog clogged pipes, or to kill or repel pests, or to clean floors and so on. Professions and entire industries are built around chemistry. Many materials encoutered around us are the products of advanced chemistry. Yet somehow we managed not to kill ourselves with phosgene or novichok. $\endgroup$ – AlexP Aug 19 at 16:26
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ You're directly equating a couple of things that I don't think you should. Just because people can do magic doesn't mean they can explode continents, just the same way even the most skilled Java Coder can't actually take over all the world's banks and just make himself an instant billionaire. You have to start by defining what the limits of magic are, and just make sure they aren't "Anybody can cast spells that make anything happen that they want". $\endgroup$ – Morris The Cat Aug 19 at 17:30
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ You will probably want to start with defining what "use magic" means to you. I'll unabashedly promote an answer I wrote for What is the smallest change to physics required to allow magic?" many years ago. It may answer your question, or it may crystallize it. You may identify some laws of physics you want magic to bend (such as conservation of energy). Then we can help you with what the consequences are of that being "easy as coding." $\endgroup$ – Cort Ammon Aug 19 at 18:13
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ And remember, while digital watches may not quite be magic, they are a nifty idea! $\endgroup$ – Cort Ammon Aug 19 at 18:15
  • $\begingroup$ Without a definition of what magic can do in this setting, this is unanswerable. "magic" is not something with know characteristics. $\endgroup$ – John Aug 19 at 18:37
3
$\begingroup$

There are many scenarios that solve your problem. Here are a few. They aren't at all mutually exclusive and probably all would work together.

Your Society is a Giant Mexican Standoff

If everyone knows magic, then how can anyone do anything bad with it without immediately being jumped by his/her peers? Literally every man, woman and child is a walking weapon of mass destruction in your society. The only way anyone can stir up trouble like that is to be orders of magnitude more powerful or to work in a group.

As others have stated, we have the entirety of chemical knowledge at our hands in our modern society. This is akin to your magic. Anyone can make nerve gas and explosives very easily and do lots of damage with chemicals that are easily available. Oklahoma city is a perfect example of this. The only thing stopping us all from making nerve gas explosives is a tacit social understanding that it is not acceptable and a misunderstanding that it is difficult.

Even so, common chemistry knowledge is abused "See: Meth Lab," but even then people are careful about it since they don't want to go to jail.

In your society, bad behavior is presumably punished, so it's going to be rare that someone will abuse magic to a massive degree.

The state police of your magical world are likely to be the most well-trained in magical combat, and as such should be able to do a relatively good job of keeping the peace.

Big Spells Should Be Difficult

You mention blowing up a continent. How plausible is it that a single person would be able to cast such a powerful spell? Nearly all magic systems require the use of mana or some other personal energy, and the energy required to cause mass destruction is almost certainly going to be proportionately massive. Such a powerful spell would likely not be something that could be easily cast, and would almost certainly not go under the radar.

Your state's magical police would likely catch wind of such a plot and attempt to disrupt it. For smaller scale destruction, you have the same problem we have with terrorists today: namely that it is nearly impossible to stop such acts of violence without good intelligence.

Someone snooping around trying to find out how to cast explosion spells or casing soft targets for attack is going to stand out, and your magic anti-terror corps is likely to identify such an individual and keep tabs on them.

Everyone Takes Responsibility for Their Own Self Defense

If everyone is taught magic, everyone is going to know how to construct defensive spells. Are you the owner of a restaurant and want to protect it from magical terrorism? Hire a professional to place magical wards of protection on your store. Some of the wards might warn of someone with evil intent, some might protect against certain types of explosion magic, others might dampen mana altogether making it difficult for people to cast magic in the first place.

Every avenue of attack has a counter, and people cast protection wards on themselves and their houses as a matter of fact. To them it's as common as locking your door at night, or dressing appropriately for the weather. People just do it as common sense.

As an aside, we have a lot of situations like this in real life. Besides the chemistry example, anyone can learn to code, and anyone can learn to hack, yet we don't have worms and viruses making life on the internet impossible. Everyone has access to kitchen knives, yet we're not all stabbing each other in the streets. There will always be bad actors, and there will always be ways of stopping them. It's a question of white hats vs black hats, and in general people are conformists to society, so there will always be more white hats than black hats in a given situation.

The difference here is it's hard to get an advantage over anyone because everyone is taught magic. So in that case, you already have an answer of how to stop people from abusing the system: education and equipment, risk vs reward. Criminals are deterred by the risk vs reward, namely that if they attack someone, there is a risk they will be overpowered by that person's magical knowledge. Since it's impossible for the criminal to know who he or she is facing, he or she must assume everyone is dangerous since everyone knows magic. Your deterrent is built in by society's education.

Criminals are in general cowards who are only violent when they feel they have an overwhelming advantage. Often when their victim pushes back they have no idea how to respond. A criminal is more confident with a gun or knife because that criminal assumes no one they face is likely to have one. When met with force, they almost invariably panic and retreat, even if their weapon has them at a distinct advantage. In most cases the criminals will likely use magic that lets them get away with their crime with the least personal risk. Muggers are likely to be less of a problem than magical pickpockets. A mugger has to assume that literally everyone they face has the ability to fight back with magic, so they will act in groups or with strong confidence. If all the criminal wants is your money, it's safer to say, use a magic spell that allows them to teleport your wallet out of your pocket. This situation maximizes the reward to the criminal while minimizing the risk. It doesn't matter how powerful their victim is, if that victim doesn't know they're under attack they can't act.

In addition, people are less likely to play the victim if the criminal has no means of intimidating them with some kind of advantage. If a 5'2" 70 pound kid walks up to you and demands your wallet, you probably won't give it to him. If the same kid walks up and points a knife at you, you're more likely to do so. If that same kid does it with a knife but now you have a gun, you're not going to hand it over this time. This is the deterrence of your magic society. Literally everyone is walking around with a gun and the understanding of how to use it.

The real dangers in your magical society will be the same as in ours: mentally unstable people who don't value their own lives. These types of people are going to lash out no matter the situation using whatever means are available and don't follow the rules of normal deterrence, but in your magic society there is a difference from ours: everyone is taught the means to defend themselves as easily as we're taught to read and write. The crazy actors will still act, but they will be quickly stopped by those around them.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

There are two fairly obvious approaches to me:

  1. What I have done with my own magic-heavy setting, also built around a rough equivalence between magic and computer programming: dangerous things are easy if you know how to do them, but knowing how to do them is the tricky part. The basics are taught to every schoolkid, so they have an idea of how their world works; they may even be asked to derive and "debug" basic spells as homework problems. But the trick to actually casting those spells, especially more dangerous ones, is a closely guarded, heavily-regulated secret. All professional magicians are under NDAs, along with significant criminal liability for teaching an untrained person how to cast. Sure, a trained and licensed magician could go rogue and blow up a continent... but so could a trained and licensed nuclear submarine captain. It's all about risk management.

  2. Simply design your magic system with limited inherent power, and/or rapid negative feedback for unskilled practitioners. E.g., I know the basics of how electrical engineering works, but I am not a professional electrician; I can build basic toy electric motors and wire up switches and outlets in my house, but I know that if I try to do much more, I risk getting a fatal shock, so I leave it to the pros. And if I want to do something that requires a really large amount of power... well, I, personally, just can't. I'd have to do some negotiating with the power company to get the resources; and for even bigger projects might only be available to government institutions that can build things like ITER or the National Ignition Facility. AlexP's chemistry analogy is also a good one: I know basic chemistry from school, but a lot of things that I theoretically know how to do are either super dangerous if done without the proper equipment and safety protocols, and I'm not dumb enough to try (like, say, making chlorine gas by mixing bleach and ammonia cleaners), or else require materials that I can't get ahold of (like, say, cryolite for refining aluminum). The end result is that, even if I am malicious enough to try to blow something up, the negative effects will be limited to a couple of city blocks at most, and there's not much chance to do more damage without either killing myself (thus naturally limiting my bad influence) or dealing with a much larger organization for manpower and resources.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

The mechanics of how to so something is not the same as having the power to do so. A person might be able to control enough magic to start a small fire close by, such as lighting a candle, but few would be able control enough energy to make a large fireball at a distance of 5 KM.

You could also have the magic be evident and the process lengthy. Everyone could detect the magic being gathered and form for a considerable time before it is activated. The caster could be physically stopped or you could even have the magic be interrupted by other magic.

$\endgroup$
1
$\begingroup$

Like Morris said, just because someone knows how to code doesn't mean they can take down the world banks from their laptop. All the world's governments and militaries have used magic to build and sustain a defense against terrorism and dark magic. Same with large companies, and common houses with people who don't invest their skills into magic are secured and certified by wizards.

Not to mention, highly destructive magic should require a lot of power. Maybe large quantities of power are held in specific locations. Ever seen the anime Little Witch Academia? You can't cast spells unless you're near the Sorcerer's Stone, which is located on campus. You could try a similar approach to that.

$\endgroup$

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.