In another question Everybody has a brain implant. What measures can a criminal take to escape justice? I assumed that a brain implant would be possible in the future for surveillance.

In this question I would like to explore the actual feasibility of such an implant from a biological stance.

My plan is to have a bionic implant that forms (or detects the firing of) synapses over a substantial area of the surface of the primary visual cortex (V1). In effect it becomes part of the brain.

My limited understanding is that V1 actually has an image distributed across its surface. This is what will get transmitted by the implant to the outside of the skull. Thus a movie of a person's visual experiences will be available for monitoring either live or in retrospect. Ignoring the technicalities of the electronic transmission through the skull, is the biology plausible with the neuroscience of the next 100 or so years? If not V1, what else could be tapped into?

My research so far has turned up the following:

V1 has a very well-defined map of the spatial information in vision. For example, in humans, the upper bank of the calcarine sulcus responds strongly to the lower half of visual field (below the center), and the lower bank of the calcarine to the upper half of visual field. In concept, this retinotopic mapping is a transformation of the visual image from retina to V1. The correspondence between a given location in V1 and in the subjective visual field is very precise: even the blind spots are mapped into V1. In terms of evolution, this correspondence is very basic and found in most animals that possess a V1. In humans and animals with a fovea in the retina, a large portion of V1 is mapped to the small, central portion of visual field, a phenomenon known as cortical magnification.[12] Perhaps for the purpose of accurate spatial encoding, neurons in V1 have the smallest receptive field size of any visual cortex microscopic regions.

  • The visual cortex does the bulk of decoding the signal from the optical nerve, but AFAIK there is more involved. All areas of the brain are involved in processing. People with damage to it may be blindedt they may still recall visual memories, for example. And if you imagine something visually, the hippocampus and frontal cortex are more involved than the visual cortex. – Renan Dec 6 at 20:55
  • 3
    Why use a brain implant at all? IIRC the actual optic nerve is a lot easier place to put a tap. This is an active field of research for artificial eyes; essentially all you're doing is making the reverse. – Cadence Dec 6 at 21:12
  • @ Cadence - I didn't know that. Could you make that into an answer? Although if you are tackling blindness by providing an alternative to (or feeding into) the the optic nerve that doesn't necessarily mean that it's the best or easiest place to tap it does it? – chasly from UK Dec 6 at 21:18

I’m not saying this isn’t possible, but what is probably easier is to map and measure every possible visual someone has in a controlled environment. Mix that in with a constant surveillance and you could give every security guard and college graduate a job watching people and then making those people think you can see through their eyes.

The problem is that most will only jump to their own conclusions based on their limited understanding of people outside their defineable parameters.

But I’m thinking, if certain wavelengths are used in unison with some metal inside a person, ie. Fillings, implants, then the frequency could disrupt synapses and leave a person distorted to reality. That mixed in with an ultra sound of keywords directed to the subconscious that present a visual to the individual might produce such visions.

Using on criminals would really only be an excuse by some research facility and would be used much more frequently on soldiers who have agreed to it obliviously.

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.