Supposing I have a room currently occupied by Jedi Knights, or some other force that I can't defeat with battle droids and brute strength. I wish to incapacitate the occupants of this room with a gas, which I will pump in using the HVAC system.

I wish to capture the intruders alive, for torment purposes. What gas can I use that will quickly incapacitate the Jedi, but that also takes the longest to kill them?

For example, if I pump VX gas into the room, the occupants with be quickly incapacitated, and killed. I wish them to pass out unconscious quickly, but still leave me a few minutes to revive them (once safely restrained) before they die.

  • 8
    Mind-controlling light-saber wielding Jedi Knights with midichlorians coursing through their veins can be knocked out with "quick-acting knockout gas". No need to get more specific. – RonJohn Nov 16 at 3:33
  • 10
    Just remember --while tormenting those clever mind-controlling telepathic telekinetic acrobatic melee virtuosos-- to avoid revealing your evil plan. – user535733 Nov 16 at 3:40
  • 4
    Quick google suggests that almost any proper incapacitation gas will also be able to kill the subject in great enough doses. It would make more sense to use an imaginary knock out gas, rather trying to figure out the perfect dose and distribution method you would need to account for the room, airflow, Alien Biology, body size and current exertion level of the Jedi, let alone if they would be able to use the force to clean the air or force it back out of the room. – Shadowzee Nov 16 at 3:43
  • 4
    Also I know this is imaginary, but wouldn't this be a pretty dangerous subject to search for? Gas that will knock someone out quickly and not kill them. I guess all of us are now on some terrorist watch list now... – Shadowzee Nov 16 at 3:45
  • 3
    pump in pot smoke or other vapor drugs - won't incapacitate but could work in a different way :) – JGreenwell Nov 16 at 3:55
up vote 25 down vote accepted

If you happen to be on a Space Station, you could simply vent the atmosphere. They may have some internal injuries, but they should revive when you pump the air back into the room.

The important thing to consider is that any "knockout" gas is a potential killer in a large enough dosage, and merely pumping it into the room is a very imprecise way of delivering the drug. Correct dosage can vary on any number of factors: age, weight race, recent activity, even what they had for breakfast that morning.

If your HVAC system is sophisticated enough you could simply replace the oxygen with nitrogen. It will cause them to fall unconscious quickly due to lack of oxygen for the brain, at which point you send in droids to restrain them. As you long as get to them within ~3 minutes and supply them with oxygen, you should be able to avoid permanent brain damage.

The advantage of this Inert Gas Asphyxiation is that there is no warning for the person, as the gas doesn't react with the body to give any sort of signal.

  • 7
    The problem with both of these approaches is that it takes time to flush the existing oxygen from the room, and if you try to speed things along, it's going to be very obvious. (Rushing fans and so forth.) So you need to make sure they're staying in one place for a prolonged period... I recommend serving dinner. – Cadence Nov 16 at 4:03
  • 6
    very few gases are edible, though :) – theRiley Nov 16 at 4:16
  • 2
    Oxygen concentration (replace by nitrogen) does not require all that much. Getting the oxygen concentration from 21% to 10% should do it. Evaporating a few liters of liquid nitrogen in a confined (small area) should achieve this very rapidly (cryogenicsociety.org/resources/defining_cryogenics/…) – GretchenV Nov 16 at 10:45
  • 3
    @Cadence: Unless that room already has some "normal" audible ventilation when you enter it, you would be none the wiser. – Martijn Nov 16 at 10:48
  • 2
    @Spratty, it is canon now that Jedi (or even force-sensitive people without Jedi training) can easily survive blasting out into vacuum of space and autonomously get back to the nearest spacecraft, while only suffering minor knockdown. – user28434 Nov 16 at 12:51

Carbon Monoxide

While perhaps not the quickest to render your enemies unconscious, the effects of low level exposure will considerably hinder their combat abilities, even if they don't get a dose high enough to knock them out.

  • impaired mental state and personality changes (intoxication)
  • vertigo – the feeling that you or the environment around you is spinning
  • ataxia – loss of physical co-ordination caused by underlying damage to the brain and nervous system
  • breathlessness and tachycardia (a heart rate of more than 100 beats per minute)
  • chest pain caused by angina or a heart attack
  • seizures – an uncontrollable burst of electrical activity in the brain that causes muscle spasms
  • loss of consciousness – in cases where there are very high levels of carbon monoxide, death may occur within minutes

Now while the force may be with them, so is the crippling headache and chest pain. Their ability to think up a cunning plan to negate your evil wiles is going to be significantly impaired.

Desflurane, isoflurane and sevoflurane are the most widely used volatile anaesthetics today. They are often combined with nitrous oxide. Older, less popular, volatile anaesthetics, include halothane, enflurane, and methoxyflurane. Researchers are also actively exploring the use of xenon as an anaesthetic. (wiki)

If its good enough for the docs, its probably good enough for your knights. I know some of that has worked on me, very quickly.

Orthochlorobenzalmalononitrile (AKA CS gas or 'tear' gas) - it won't actually knock them out but it will definitely incapacitate them very quickly unless they happen to have full-face respirators handy.

Holding their breath won't help them (ala Messers Kenobi and Qui-gon in Ep 1) as it doesn't need to be breathed in to do it's work - it's primarily an irritant and not even Jedi Knights do their best work when their nostrils, eyes and skin feel like they are on fire!

No worries about killing them (unless they are elderly or have a pre-existing respiratory or cardiac condition) and bonus points in that it's unpleasant enough to start the torment!

Lots of organic molecules, particularly those that feature benzenes, can cause incapacitation and unconsciousness extremely quickly without requiring that ambient oxygen be removed.

The problems noted in other answers still exist (HVAC delivery will be crazily imprecise for dosage, and a sufficient amount to ensure unconsciousness for everyone has a good chance of killing at least someone), plus exposure to benzenes can have a lot of long-term health consequences (which may not matter for your needs here).

I don't recall the exact molecule, I remember one time when I was in an organic chemistry lab and got too close (my face was ~2 feet away, distance mostly but not entirely vertical) to the open top of a flask full of a benzene-containing liquid. My muscles gave out in a heartbeat and I immediately collapsed to the floor and had no physical ability to resist in any way and nearly lost consciousness. From a single, incomplete inhalation!

How about using oxygen?

The Jedi will likely notice you reducing the oxygen, but if you increase pressure in the room and change the air to a higher oxygen purity you'll induce hyperoxia or oxygen toxicity: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxygen_toxicity

This causes disorientation, spasms, near-sightedness and more, more than 15 minutes of exposure is more than enough to incapacitate them. As far as I can tell age and bodyweight have little effect on the effects so this is indoscriminate as long as all subjects are equally active.

Otherwise there is almost nothing that will work. Here's the wiki about gasses that cause sleep, unconsciousness or other forms of incapacitation: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incapacitating_agent

It specifically states that the US for example looked at ways to knock out hijackers of aircraft but found none that guaranteed survival of the hostages as agression or hazards of the gas itself can kill, such as during the 2002 russian hostage situation where 15% of 800 hostages died after exposure to the (unknown) gas. Considering the amount of targets (2 Jedi), their similar physiology (both grown and trained adults) and that you can immediately offer proper medical assistance the chance of death can definitely be reduced.

I would discard the notions of some of your other advisors, mainly the one of "the dosage to knock out vs kill differs from person to person therefore you cannot use it". While true, the margin of error depends on your targets and gas used. If you have a 7 foot tall Jedi bodybuilder in the prime of his life with a 6 year old padawan the chance of over or underdosing either one is huge, if they are of similar build and age you calculate the potential dosage to knock out the one with the least bodyweight, reduce that dosage a little and use a gas that incapacitates or reduces capabilities before that to make sure neither one will die but they are easier to capture.

Edit: The only other solution is oxygen deprivation by sucking the air out, rather than deprivation by replacing oxygen. If you simply replace the oxygen and your oversensitive Jedi notice it, they put on those rebreather thingies and escape. But if you suck the air out to a low enough content then their best bet is to exhale as much air or their lungs might burst, and they'll lose consciousness quickly. (https://www.scienceabc.com/pure-sciences/what-happens-to-a-human-body-if-exposed-to-the-vacuum-of-space.html).

The beauty of this is ofcourse that you can announce it to your Jedi: "hey we'll suck the oxygen out now thank you". The Jedi will try to survive as long as possible and exhale. Now you'll lower the oxygen content slow enough that lung bursting won't be a problem as the Jedi will lose consciousness before that, but they won't know that! The best part is that if you get the room pressurised and oxynegated quickly they'll not have any permanent damage, as evidenced by both some rather nasty experiments with dogs and an unlucky astronaught who had an accident inside a chamber, lost consciousness and made a full recovery. Within that time period that your Jedi are still unconscious or recovering from it, you can easily sedate them with something in the bloodstream and then just hook them up to some aneastetics to keep them under until you have them bound, not gagged so they can make quips about their terrible situation and you fail to search their body's so they have something hidden to cut the ropes and make a daring escape as you leave them in a truly deadly situation but don't watch them die (ropes on your space station? Why ofcourse! I put them next to my goatee oil!). I was going to interrogate them? Oh I'll forget about all that as I'm practicing my moustache twirling and make some exposition about my masterplan of ruling the planet by forcing the queen to sign a peace treaty after having her walk through a city with minimal protection and using convoluted politics.

If you watch the movies, they put on gas masks as soon as the gas gets pumped.

The best solution is a nerve agent such as Sarin which only has to touch the skin. They have at best a few minutes and leaving the room won't even help

If you want them alive you administer the antidote (preferably by droid) otherwise just wait for them to drop dead.

  • 2
    Sarin is an extremely potent nerve agent. I asked for incapacitation. – kingledion Nov 16 at 13:30
  • Then apply the antidote as I said. Anything short of a powerful nerve agent is going to end badly for you. – Thorne Nov 18 at 22:24

You use your super ability to produce large volumes of noxious farts.

A typical fart is composed of about 59 percent nitrogen, 21 percent hydrogen, 9 percent carbon dioxide, 7 percent methane and 4 percent oxygen. Only about one percent of a fart contains hydrogen sulfide gas and mercaptans, which contain sulfur, and the sulfur is what makes farts stink.

https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-composition-of-the-human-fart

As far as I know, no-one has ever died from breathing in a fart but in large amounts it would surely incapacitate almost anyone or at least make them surrender or want to run away.

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.