The testicle or testis is the male reproductive gland in all animals, including you humans. It is homologous to the female ovary. The functions of the testes are to produce both sperm and androgens, primarily testosterone. Approximately 300 million sperm cells are produced daily, with millions made every minute. Your testicles are housed outside the body, and are therefore very vulnerable to extrmeties, as well as being subjected to being kicked. While hilarious, it does not lead to successfully conducive reproductive capabilities.

I would like to create my own humanoid species without this design flaw, but modeled off of your species, and have the testes inside the body rather than out. However, there is a problem. Too much heat is deadly to sperm. The body's temperature would kill the millions of sperm being produced, effectively making males sterile.

How can I get past this conundrum?

  • 18
    Am I missing something that makes "have the sperm be heat resistant" not the answer? – RonJohn Nov 8 at 17:58
  • 8
    Worth noting: we do not yet understand why spermatogenesis occurs best at temperatures below body temperature. There's several competing theories, but its still a mystery. – Cort Ammon Nov 8 at 18:15
  • 2
    @MonkeyZeus If there was a lot of low to the ground testy consuming predators, then logically people would evolve to have them internalized. – Trevor D Nov 8 at 19:21
  • @Cort Ammon - any reference to what the leading theories are? Seems odd that this one particular function (of all the hundreds or thousands of other) would need such special treatment. – Mike Wise Nov 8 at 22:00
  • Ah, the old honeybadger defense tactic. – Flater Nov 9 at 8:01

However, there is a problem. Too much heat is deadly to sperm. The body's temperature would kill the millions of sperm being produced, effectively making males sterile.

How can I get past this conundrum?

By doing what nature does with species that have internal testes but need to keep the sperm from dying of excess heat.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Testicle#Internal

The basal condition for mammals is to have internal testes.[25] The testes of the non-boreotherian mammals, such as the monotremes, armadillos, sloths, and elephants, remain within the abdomen.[not in citation given][26] There are also some marsupials with external testes[27] and Boreoeutherian mammals with internal testes, such as the rhinoceros.[28] Cetaceans such as whales and dolphins also have internal testes.[29] As external testes would increase drag in the water they have internal testes which are kept cool by special circulatory systems that cool the arterial blood going to the testes by placing the arteries near veins bringing cooled venous blood from the skin.[30][31]

Humans already have the ability (though unconscious mostly) to extend and retract their testicles. So just increase this ability so you can retract all the way inside yourself, and they only descend when aroused, therefore they start producing sperm at that time. You could add some sort of sphincter muscle that closes behind them and protects them when stressed so it's still an automated biological response. Technically you would not be damaging the sperm because they simply aren't being created while the testicles are being stored.

Mating rituals would be modified to last an hour or so to allow a large enough number of sperm to be created before they are needed.

  • 5
    Sumo fighters can retract them all the way on demand. Usually before fight — given how their wardrobe works this is a requirement, not an option. – Mołot Nov 8 at 18:37
  • 6
    @Mołot I suddenly have even more respect for those guys – Trevor D Nov 8 at 19:23
  • 1
    straightdope.com/columns/read/73/… Not sure if this is a correct source, that debunks the myth – TCSGrad Nov 8 at 22:02
  • 3
    @TrevorD: The process takes about 35-40 days, not a matter of minutes or hours. – R.. Nov 9 at 1:28
  • @R.. Then make the ritual take weeks. Paternal leave suddenly means something totally different, means your off performing a month long ritual to get your wife pregnant. There's a ton of potential storylines just around that. – Trevor D Nov 9 at 14:18

Just do what marine mammals do: keep them well inside the body!

enter image description here

This article describes some ancient research that revealed that cetaceans keep their testes cool by a curious arrangement of blood vessels in that region. Basically, your humans could do the same: develop a network of blood vessels designed to locally regulate the temperature of the tissues surrounding the testes.

For your reading pleasure: Temperature regulation of the testes of the bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus): evidence from colonic temperatures

Dolphins possess a countercurrent heat exchanger that functions to cool their intra-abdominal testes. Spermatic arteries in the posterior abdomen are juxtaposed to veins returning cooled blood from the surfaces of the dorsal fin and flukes

Yes, there are diagrams.

Your post is based on the assumption that testes evolved to keep sperm cool. There is actually no evidence for this. It could well be the opposite, that sperm evolved to like it cooler because it's in the testes.

Given how much of a vulnerability testes (not just the final form, also how they develop) are, it seems much more economical to evolve sperm with higher heat resistance. Elephants and birds, for instance, have a high body temperature and no respective cooling mechanism.

Testes evolved independently in marsupials and placentals, so they seem to be solving an important problem. But if that problem was temperature, then birds and elephants should have them, too.

TLDR: The cooling problem is easily solved, but we don't really know why humanoids (in particular) need testes, so your species might suffer from other problems.

For a humanoid species (that is, bipedal but not related to homo sapiens) you really don't have to worry. You can just make testicles internal. We have no good idea why Earth mammals commonly, but not always, have external testes. Therefore we have to reason to generalise and expect external testicles in all bipedal body plans.

The heat hypothesis is popular in pop-sci articles but has no useful evidence nor mechanisms to explain its evolution. For starters: mammals begin 220 million years ago and the scrotum evolves twice in lineages about 70 and 100 million years later, so we have many millions of years of hot, internal testicles to explain.

For my money, the better bet is that testicles are damaged by the fluctuating abdominal pressures of running and galloping mammals (usefully aligns with current populations of scrotum/not-scrotum mammals and the rough evolution of these gaits).

Therefore you can explain that this species didn't evolve such fragile reproductive organs, or that they are located in a protective casing of some sort.

Yes, yes, whales, dolphins; just so. Cool blood - very sensible. But air is cooler than blood.
I propose the testes be located where they can be cooled by that cool cool air.

mumps source

This local is optimally suited to provide varying flows of cooling air. Mouthbreathing can facilitate cooling of the testicles under conditions of heat; conversely nosebreathing in cold weather will keep the testicles warmer.

Relocation of the sperm producing organs to this site would also mean that the male penis (also prone to damage in an exposed area) would not be necessary, and urinary apparatus could be relocated back into the safety of the bony pelvis - along the lines of the much more sensible human female body plan.

  • Air is much less dense than water, and thus cools less effectively. More importantly, a stuffed nose in the winter results in mouth breathing. – RonJohn Nov 9 at 14:36
  • @RonJohn - heat cannot be destroyed, only moved from place to place. When your own body cools itself, what then warms up? I am not talking about when you are swimming. – Willk Nov 9 at 21:56
  • "only moved from place to place". Denser materials do that moving much more efficiently than less dense materials. That's why testicles in the (warm) mouth cooled by air is less efficient than testicles in the warm body cooled by less warm blood. – RonJohn Nov 9 at 22:00

Your Answer

 

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.