I'd like some reality check advices about the following village set in a fantasy world vaguely resembling early-to-middle medieval Europe in our world. Note the phrase "vaguely resembling": I'm consciously making this a much more liberal, friendlier and safer world.
Let's call the village Brillam. Brillam is a small village housing around 400 people, along a mountain path to the neighboring country. The path takes as short as 7 days on foot, but is rather rough. Attempts to make the path smoother have failed for both economic and technological limits. Brillam's main source of income is from the traffic through this path.
Below Brillam, on a flatter land is a larger town named Alensus, housing around 2000 people. Brillam and Alensus are one day's travel apart. Alensus is along another path to the same neighboring country, which takes at least 10 days but is smoother, allowing carts and carriages to pass through. The difference this makes is that large caravans and wealthy individuals would almost certainly travel through Alensus, and traffic through Brillam would be limited to people who prefer speed such as messengers, merchants on horseback, and people who have business in the mountain. This makes Alensus much more prosperous than Brillam, although Brillam still has enough traffic to get itself going.
Now, I'm considering an idea that Brillam does have a resource it could use to improve its economy, which is a geyser nearby. Not the only geyser in the mountain, but certainly something that Alensus doesn't have around. The path to the geyser isn't exactly a short picnic and the spring itself is quite small (fits only like 8 people), so the people of Brillam haven't really thought of using it to attract travellers, but one day an innkeeper decides it's worth a try. The innkeeper makes a heavy investment to build a nice path to the geyser and through some fantasy application expands the geyser to be able to hold more people. (Assume that legal matters with the lord are no problem.)
I'm supposing that Brillam won't have to worry about taking away traffic from Alensus and spoiling the relations with it, because the path along Brillam is still rough. Rich people in carriages whose top priority isn't speed would simply visit Brillam for the hot springs and then continue through Alensus. There would be some interest in building a smoother path along Brillam, but assume that both settlements know this won't happen any time soon.
So there are three things I'd like to do reality check for.
- Is the current state of the two villages realistic?
- Will a hot spring, given enough publicity, be able to create a meaningful increase in traffic to Brillam? If so, how soon will Brillam see the effects?
- Am I right in guessing that Brillam's new hot springs wouldn't upset Alensus by taking away customers? Is there anything that either settlement could do to change the situation in a short time?
Assume that Brillam and Alensus are on very good terms, and even if otherwise, neither settlement would try to do gain profit at the expense of economically dooming the other, such as Alensus blocking off the route to Brillam.
Even if everything looks okay (which I doubt), any advices to further refine the idea are very much welcome.