Skip to main content
added 200 characters in body
Source Link
dsollen
  • 33.9k
  • 8
  • 110
  • 227

KidneyEDIT: as BrianDHall said kidney transplants.. are not quite as doable as I thought.those may However, many other surgeries would be doableplausible, though less effective, If a surgeon trained in the older surgery techniques were sent back. Surgery is more about knowing the body and how it works, it is less dependent on specialized tools (relatively speaking!!). The biggest issue would be lack of proper anesthesia and sanitation. Still, these would only lower success ratelimited ability for sanitation (basic boiled water can be used, but it's not remove it. If you take someone trained in the old-fashioned plan-old-scalpel method of kidney donation and you put him with people who were going to die SOON withoutsame as a kidneyproper sterile operation enviroment), and a bunchlack of cadavers..well he wouldn't see the success rates we see today, butdrugs to control infection and/or body immune response(though as I said a few peoplebasic antibiotic could theoretically be saved. In fact many surgeries are similar,created in a few people trained in the older fashioned (non robotyears, non-sensor assistedpenicillin was just moldy bread after all!) surgery could do most of them. Their success rates would be much This means a lower due to the lacksuccess rate of proper sanitationsurgeries, it's hard to get a real clean-room inbut if it was life or death then a castle. Lacksurgery with risk of anesthesia can lead to shock andinfection is still better then death! Which surgeries are possible and which aren't really comes down to rather they needed specialized drugs pre or post operation, butand how hard it wasn't until sadly very recently that we usedis to operate on a patient that is not under anesthesia on infants (they actually thoughtie that newborns couldn't feel anything), andcould move while there were more lives lost due to shock most still came out fineyour doing a percise cut) I would assume. I admit I'm less knowledgeable in this area.

Kidney transplants...those may be doable. The biggest issue would be lack of proper anesthesia and sanitation. Still, these would only lower success rate, not remove it. If you take someone trained in the old-fashioned plan-old-scalpel method of kidney donation and you put him with people who were going to die SOON without a kidney and a bunch of cadavers..well he wouldn't see the success rates we see today, but a few people could be saved. In fact many surgeries are similar, a few people trained in the older fashioned (non robot, non-sensor assisted) surgery could do most of them. Their success rates would be much lower due to the lack of proper sanitation, it's hard to get a real clean-room in a castle. Lack of anesthesia can lead to shock and death, but it wasn't until sadly very recently that we used on anesthesia on infants (they actually thought that newborns couldn't feel anything), and while there were more lives lost due to shock most still came out fine.

EDIT: as BrianDHall said kidney transplants are not quite as doable as I thought. However, many other surgeries would be plausible, though less effective, If a surgeon trained in the older surgery techniques were sent back. Surgery is more about knowing the body and how it works, it is less dependent on specialized tools (relatively speaking!!). The biggest issue would be lack of proper anesthesia, limited ability for sanitation (basic boiled water can be used, but it's not the same as a proper sterile operation enviroment), and lack of drugs to control infection and/or body immune response(though as I said a basic antibiotic could theoretically be created in a few years, penicillin was just moldy bread after all!) . This means a lower success rate of surgeries, but if it was life or death then a surgery with risk of infection is still better then death! Which surgeries are possible and which aren't really comes down to rather they needed specialized drugs pre or post operation, and how hard it is to operate on a patient that is not under anesthesia (ie that could move while your doing a percise cut) I would assume. I admit I'm less knowledgeable in this area.

added 25 characters in body
Source Link
dsollen
  • 33.9k
  • 8
  • 110
  • 227

Kidney transplants...those may be doable. The biggest issue would be lack of proper anesthesia and sanitation. Still, these would only lower success rate, not remove it. If you take someone trained in the old-fashioned plan-old-scalpel method of kidney donation and you put him with people who were going to die SOON without a kidney and a bunch of cadavers..well he wouldn't see the success rates we see today, but a few people could be saved. In fact many surgeries are similar, a few people trained in the older fashioned (non robot, non-sensor assisted) surgery could do most of them. Their success rates would be much lower due to the lack of proper sanitation, it's hard to get a real clean-room in a castle. Lack of anesthesia can lead to shock and death, but it wasn't until sadly very recently that we used on anesthesia on infants (they actually thought that newborns couldn't feel anything), and while there were more lives lost due to shock most still came out fine.

Some cool things that could be theoretically done by a lone person with any STEM education, intellect, some support from the 'natives', and perhaps an interest in science (but no very unique or specialized skills beyond high school) are:

Some cool things that could be theoretically done by a lone person with any STEM education, intellect, some support from the 'natives', and perhaps an interest in science (but no very unique or specialized skills beyond high school) are:

Kidney transplants...those may be doable. The biggest issue would be lack of proper anesthesia and sanitation. Still, these would only lower success rate, not remove it. If you take someone trained in the old-fashioned plan-old-scalpel method of kidney donation and you put him with people who were going to die SOON without a kidney and a bunch of cadavers..well he wouldn't see the success rates we see today, but a few people could be saved. In fact many surgeries are similar, a few people trained in the older fashioned (non robot, non-sensor assisted) surgery could do most of them. Their success rates would be much lower due to the lack of proper sanitation, it's hard to get a real clean-room in a castle. Lack of anesthesia can lead to shock and death, but it wasn't until sadly very recently that we used on anesthesia on infants (they actually thought that newborns couldn't feel anything), and while there were more lives lost due to shock most still came out fine.

Some cool things that could be theoretically done by a lone person with any STEM education, intellect, some support from the 'natives', and perhaps an interest in science (but no very unique or specialized skills beyond high school) are:

added 25 characters in body
Source Link
dsollen
  • 33.9k
  • 8
  • 110
  • 227

The problem is that of building tools. I can't just build a computer with the help of a blacksmith. I need very exact tools to fit 10^8 circuits per square centimeter of chip. To build automated tools that exact I would need, in turn, other special tools, which I would need specialized tools to build etc etc. Even doing everything perfectly it's just not possible to go from middle age tools to computer age tools in 50 years, it takes too long to build all the intermediate, slightly more resigned, tools in succession.

The problem is that of building tools. I can't just build a computer with the help of a blacksmith. I need very exact tools to fit 10^8 circuits per square centimeter of chip. To build automated tools that exact I would need, in turn, other special tools, which I would need specialized tools to build etc etc. Even doing everything perfectly it's just not possible to go from middle age tools to computer age tools in 50 years, it takes too long to build all the intermediate tools in succession.

The problem is that of building tools. I can't just build a computer with the help of a blacksmith. I need very exact tools to fit 10^8 circuits per square centimeter of chip. To build automated tools that exact I would need, in turn, other special tools, which I would need specialized tools to build etc etc. Even doing everything perfectly it's just not possible to go from middle age tools to computer age tools in 50 years, it takes too long to build all the intermediate, slightly more resigned, tools in succession.

added 3656 characters in body
Source Link
dsollen
  • 33.9k
  • 8
  • 110
  • 227
Loading
Source Link
dsollen
  • 33.9k
  • 8
  • 110
  • 227
Loading