Skip to main content
Made a few spelling edits that were bothering me and made it slightly less brutal.
Source Link

It is possible in theory, but not the way it is shown in the movies. First of all, the human neck is both strong and flexible, and unless the person is taken unaware (like in a car accident), will automatically tense up in response to pressure, making it even stronger. Second, even if you could muster enough strength to break a neck, unless the rest of the body was restrained you would just end up twisting their entire body around.

The only way to pull off a snapping someones neck snap realistically is by getting the victim in a full-body grapplehold, then stretching and twisting the neck until it breaks. You'd need to be very strong to do it though; flexibility alone isn't going to cutbe enough to snap it.

It may, however, be possible to break someone's neck with an impact instead of a twist. A strong punch or kick may generateproduce enough force, but only if the body was restrained somehow, so not really practical in a fight. It may be possible to get them in a hold and then throw yourself and them onto the floor with enough force to twist their neck to the breaking point, but this would involve more luck than anything. This may be the best option to use in a story though - makethis makes it basically a lucky flukematter of luck.

It won't be an instant-kill in any event;matter; even if you fully paralyze the person from the neck down they'll still be alive until they suffocate. More likely than not they won't be fully paralyzed and you'll instead be left with a paraplegic who is perfectly capable of talking (or screaming). Think about the possible results of car accident neck injuries from a car accident. Those are basically the results you'll get from trying to do this if you dont instant kill them.(You Won't So Please Don't Attempt This)

All in all, it's notthis isn't a very effective killing maneuver, even with brute force and extreme flexibility.

It is possible in theory, but not the way it is shown in the movies. First of all, the human neck is both strong and flexible, and unless the person is taken unaware (like in a car accident), will automatically tense up in response to pressure, making it even stronger. Second, even if you could muster enough strength to break a neck, unless the rest of the body was restrained you would just end up twisting their entire body around.

The only way to pull off a neck snap realistically is by getting the victim in a full-body grapple, then stretching and twisting the neck until it breaks. You'd need to be very strong to do it though; flexibility alone isn't going to cut it.

It may, however, be possible to break someone's neck with an impact instead of a twist. A strong punch or kick may generate enough force, but only if the body was restrained somehow, so not really practical in a fight. It may be possible to get them in a hold and then throw yourself and them onto the floor with enough force to twist their neck to the breaking point, but this would involve more luck than anything. This may be the best option to use in a story though - make it basically a lucky fluke.

It won't be an instant-kill in any event; even if you fully paralyze the person from the neck down they'll still be alive until they suffocate. More likely than not they won't be fully paralyzed and you'll instead be left with a paraplegic who is perfectly capable of talking (or screaming). Think about the possible results of car accident neck injuries.

All in all, it's not a very effective killing maneuver.

It is possible in theory, but not the way it is shown in the movies. First of all, the human neck is both strong and flexible, and unless the person is taken unaware (like in a car accident), will automatically tense up in response to pressure, making it even stronger. Second, even if you could muster enough strength to break a neck, unless the rest of the body was restrained you would just end up twisting their entire body around.

The only way to pull off a snapping someones neck realistically is by getting the victim in a full-body hold, then stretching and twisting the neck until it breaks. You'd need to be very strong to do it though; flexibility alone isn't going to be enough to snap it.

It may, however, be possible to break someone's neck with an impact instead of a twist. A strong punch or kick may produce enough force, but only if the body was restrained somehow, so not really practical in a fight. It may be possible to get them in a hold and then throw yourself and them onto the floor with enough force to twist their neck to the breaking point, but this would involve more luck than anything. This may be the best option to use in a story though - this makes it basically a matter of luck.

It won't be an instant-kill in any matter; even if you fully paralyze the person from the neck down they'll still be alive until they suffocate. More likely than not they won't be fully paralyzed and you'll instead be left with a paraplegic who is perfectly capable of talking (or screaming). Think about the possible results neck injuries from a car accident. Those are basically the results you'll get from trying to do this if you dont instant kill them.(You Won't So Please Don't Attempt This)

All in all, this isn't a very effective killing maneuver, even with brute force and extreme flexibility.

deleted 89 characters in body
Source Link
IndigoFenix
  • 29.2k
  • 3
  • 69
  • 120

It is possible in theory, but not the way it is shown in the movies. First of all, the human neck is both strong and flexible, and unless the person is taken unaware (like in a car accident), will automatically tense up in response to pressure, making it even stronger. Second, even if you could muster enough strength to break a neck, unless the rest of the body was restrained you would just end up twisting their entire body around.

The only way to pull off a neck snap realistically is by getting the victim in a full-body grapple, then stretching and twisting the neck until it breaks. You'd need to be very strong to do it though, like professional wrestler strong (and the victim would need to have weak neck muscles);though; flexibility alone isn't going to cut it.

It may, however, be possible to break someone's neck with an impact instead of a twist. A strong punch or kick may generate enough force, but only if the body was restrained somehow, so not really practical in a fight. It may be possible to get them in a hold and then throw yourself and them onto the floor with enough force to twist their neck to the breaking point, but this would involve more luck than anything. This may be the best option to use in a story though - make it basically a lucky fluke.

It won't be an instant-kill in any event; even if you fully paralyze the person from the neck down they'll still be alive until they suffocate. More likely than not they won't be fully paralyzed and you'll instead be left with a paraplegic who is perfectly capable of talking (or screaming). Think about the possible results of car accident neck injuries.

All in all, it's not a very effective killing maneuver.

It is possible in theory, but not the way it is shown in the movies. First of all, the human neck is both strong and flexible, and unless the person is taken unaware (like in a car accident), will automatically tense up in response to pressure, making it even stronger. Second, even if you could muster enough strength to break a neck, unless the rest of the body was restrained you would just end up twisting their entire body around.

The only way to pull off a neck snap realistically is by getting the victim in a full-body grapple, then stretching and twisting the neck until it breaks. You'd need to be very strong to do it though, like professional wrestler strong (and the victim would need to have weak neck muscles); flexibility alone isn't going to cut it.

It may, however, be possible to break someone's neck with an impact instead of a twist. A strong punch or kick may generate enough force, but only if the body was restrained somehow, so not really practical in a fight. It may be possible to get them in a hold and then throw yourself and them onto the floor with enough force to twist their neck to the breaking point, but this would involve more luck than anything. This may be the best option to use in a story though - make it basically a lucky fluke.

It won't be an instant-kill in any event; even if you fully paralyze the person from the neck down they'll still be alive until they suffocate. More likely than not they won't be fully paralyzed and you'll instead be left with a paraplegic who is perfectly capable of talking (or screaming). Think about the possible results of car accident neck injuries.

All in all, it's not a very effective killing maneuver.

It is possible in theory, but not the way it is shown in the movies. First of all, the human neck is both strong and flexible, and unless the person is taken unaware (like in a car accident), will automatically tense up in response to pressure, making it even stronger. Second, even if you could muster enough strength to break a neck, unless the rest of the body was restrained you would just end up twisting their entire body around.

The only way to pull off a neck snap realistically is by getting the victim in a full-body grapple, then stretching and twisting the neck until it breaks. You'd need to be very strong to do it though; flexibility alone isn't going to cut it.

It may, however, be possible to break someone's neck with an impact instead of a twist. A strong punch or kick may generate enough force, but only if the body was restrained somehow, so not really practical in a fight. It may be possible to get them in a hold and then throw yourself and them onto the floor with enough force to twist their neck to the breaking point, but this would involve more luck than anything. This may be the best option to use in a story though - make it basically a lucky fluke.

It won't be an instant-kill in any event; even if you fully paralyze the person from the neck down they'll still be alive until they suffocate. More likely than not they won't be fully paralyzed and you'll instead be left with a paraplegic who is perfectly capable of talking (or screaming). Think about the possible results of car accident neck injuries.

All in all, it's not a very effective killing maneuver.

Source Link
IndigoFenix
  • 29.2k
  • 3
  • 69
  • 120

It is possible in theory, but not the way it is shown in the movies. First of all, the human neck is both strong and flexible, and unless the person is taken unaware (like in a car accident), will automatically tense up in response to pressure, making it even stronger. Second, even if you could muster enough strength to break a neck, unless the rest of the body was restrained you would just end up twisting their entire body around.

The only way to pull off a neck snap realistically is by getting the victim in a full-body grapple, then stretching and twisting the neck until it breaks. You'd need to be very strong to do it though, like professional wrestler strong (and the victim would need to have weak neck muscles); flexibility alone isn't going to cut it.

It may, however, be possible to break someone's neck with an impact instead of a twist. A strong punch or kick may generate enough force, but only if the body was restrained somehow, so not really practical in a fight. It may be possible to get them in a hold and then throw yourself and them onto the floor with enough force to twist their neck to the breaking point, but this would involve more luck than anything. This may be the best option to use in a story though - make it basically a lucky fluke.

It won't be an instant-kill in any event; even if you fully paralyze the person from the neck down they'll still be alive until they suffocate. More likely than not they won't be fully paralyzed and you'll instead be left with a paraplegic who is perfectly capable of talking (or screaming). Think about the possible results of car accident neck injuries.

All in all, it's not a very effective killing maneuver.